Slimelite BBS

Brains

Back to APRIL

From Martyn Harrison · 1996-04-08 15:35 · #76437 in APRIL

BA>All this talk about consciousness. Is it just a "side effect" of having
BA>a large brain compared to other life forms ? Is it just a fluke that we

I haven't heard any convincing definitions. We did this one to death a
while back over something called "The Chinese Room". A man in a room
takes messages fed under the door, refers to books of instructions and
then pushes replies back. He does not know Chinese.

To the person pushing messages under the door, the room appears to know
Chinese, but since neither the man in the room nor the room itself
understands chinese, this is mistaken.

To simplify the argument, a computer which is following a program can't
be conscious, nor would a human being whose thinking is programmed in be
actually thinking. Consciousness and free will seem to be interelated, a
knife is not a murderer, the person who holds the knife is doing the
killing. So a computer isn't thinking, the programmer who wrote the
program is responsible for what the computer says.

BA>level IYSWIM. Our minds seem to have more "IF / THEN" type decisions going
BA>on all the time. Is it because of this that we are the most conscious of
BA>all the species on this planet ?

If/then and other predetermined decisions are not consious. It's the
break from the routine which "wakes" consciousness up.

BA>When our brain dies, this "side effect" dies with it. We don't go to any
BA>"afterlife". The "I" dies. It's hard to understand "nothingness" now, but it
BA>doesn't matter because we won't be "there" to have to understand it IYSWIM.

How do you know? <g>

---
 * TLX v4.10 * Let he who is without conscience cast the first stone...

--- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.12 
 * Origin: Ooh! BBS, London [MULTILINES]  0181-395-3108  (2:254/233.0)