From Kieron Dunbar · 1996-04-11 20:05 · #76412 in APRIL
In reply to Re: Just a thought ... by Paul West
Once upon a time, Paul West wrote to Brian Allan thus: PW> kind of general thing. Personally I do not believe that anything is the PW> result of anything else, and if we happen to have a large brain So if I were to hit you with a large mallet, you wouldn't believe that that was causing the feeling of pain you might be experiencing? :) PW> If we're being tangible about it, though, you could either say that PW> large consciousness is the result of a large brain, or that a large PW> brain is a result of large consciousness. Which would you choose? It I'd say the `large' consciousness was a result of having a large brain, because the large brain is due to evolution, nothing else. PW> subjective choice because logically neither is truer than the other. I Why not? PW> With astrology for example, people /usually/ say that the position of PW> planets and the sun influences us - has a causal effect on us. However, PW> that is not so. The reason it is possible for it TO have an effect is PW> due to its acausal relationship with us - thus it is a reflection of us PW> and we a reflection of it. No, the `it's are huge masses of rock, gas or whatever, which we have no influence over. They exist with no reference to us, so can't be a reflection of us. BA>> It seems to me that all life forms do the same basic things BA>> that we do except on a more basic level IYSWIM. PW> Yes, they do. Humans do what the universe does, only on a smaller PW> level. The universe is, IMO, the sum of everything. How can that be done on a smaller level? BA>> Our minds seem to have BA>> more "IF / THEN" type decisions going on all the time. PW> I might add that the mind does NOT work using language. Just because But how else would you represent how it does work? Logic seems to be the most, well, logical, way of doing it. PW> The only thing which sets man apart from all over life forms is his PW> ability to realise his true self. If you neglect that ability, you are Could you explain that a bit? What do you mean by `true self'? PW> `life' thing which determines that the body isn't dead. When the body PW> dies, all that's happened is that the `life' thing is removed from the PW> body. This does NOT mean it is removed from existence, especially not It doesn't mean that it isn't, either. PW> truly measure this `soul' in a physical way. The difference between a PW> living person and a dead person is that the living person has awareness. Depending on how you define person, you could say one difference is that a dead person is far more likely to get eaten. BA>> We don't go to any "afterlife". PW> We most certainly do. The problem is this... Why so certainly? PW> The physical world is an extreme end of a scale. There is a scale going PW> from infinity down to what we call finity - the physcalness of this What you call finity, you mean. I've never come across the term... PW> If you ONLY live in the physical end of the scale, you only experience PW> the physical end, normally. Because it depicts so clearly the largest D'you mean, living in the physical universe, you experience only the physical universe? I'd agree with that. PW> of `solid reality', we think that as soon as that physicality is taken PW> away there will be none left for there to be another place to exist. PW> This is flawed. How, and why, is it flawed? PW> Just because you take away a huge chunk of physicality when you die, it PW> does not work in a tangible way. You have to have a different paradigm PW> to PW> understand this properly. If you're in a paradigm where tangibility PW> means PW> truth, which is the usual paradigm to be in nowadays, you make PW> measurements PW> and you have quantities of things. Thus, if you put together all the PW> physical world you know of and call it a whole, having never recalled PW> an PW> experience beyond it, you say that `this' is all there is. Thus you PW> attribute pretty much 100% to the amount of physicalness there is here. PW> So PW> what's left for `there'? Nothing. So you conclude there is nothing PW> beyond PW> death. PW> However, the only reason you say that the physical world is the whole PW> is because you've not experienced anything beyond it, or what you can You are, I take it, familiar with Occam's razor? Why shouldn't any notion of `other worlds' be rejected? PW> there. Just because you can't measure God it doesn't mean he isn't there. But what reason is there to suggest that he is? PW> of proof is found where things are infinite. Just because you cannot PW> physically measure anything beyond what you experience or have been PW> experiencing here in the physical, that does not qualify you to make PW> judgements of things which are beyond the physical world. Far from it. But you have to use your own judgement to decide whether this is correct. How do you justify that? PW> Second, you exist, you be, you are. When you die, you stop perceiving PW> the physical. This does not mean you stop perceiving because perception PW> is made possible by way of the beingness part of things. Thus, you must What do you mean by `the beingness part of things'? And why should it continue after death? PW> at least `BE' when you are physically dead. As the physical is only one PW> end of a scale, it would be safe to assume that there are many other Why do you think it is only one end of a scale? PW> No. If the world is purely physical, it is one thing, a tangible PW> *limited* continuum. As such, it is one thing. Being one thing, it is NOT The world is just a ball of rock, which defines its limits fairly precisely. However, the universe has no limits that I have any reason to suppose exist. PW> possible for there to be contrast. Thus there could not possibly be a PW> physical apparatus looking at a physical thing and knowing that it's What do you mean? I can know that (for instance) my computer is there, because all the evidence suggests that it is. PW> Thus, the `I' does NOT die when the physical level dies, because the PW> `I' is not and cannot be physical. Why not? BA>> It's hard to understand "nothingness" PW> There is no such thing as nothingness. Just because God is indifferent Nothingness doesn't exist, because if it did it wouldn't be nothing... There were a few things saying that things do not prove certain things, but no explanation for why there is any suggestion otherwise, here. kwaheri, Kieron Internet : ksches@rmplc.co.uk --- Spot 1.3a Unregistered * Origin: I don't claim to know everything. I don't have to. (2:442/103.11)