From Paul West · 1996-04-05 00:38 · #76389 in APRIL
In reply to Just a thought ... by Brian Allan
On 31-Mar-96, something quite extraordinary happened. You revealed to All that it was to do with "Just a thought ..."! Jolly good show Brian! BA> I was thinking ............ :) Let's not confuse what was with what is. ;) BA> All this talk about consciousness. Is it just a "side effect" of BA> having a large brain compared to other life forms ? Only if you're philospohy is one which enables you to HAVE `side effects'. Such a philosphy would surely be in some way linear, cause-effect, that kind of general thing. Personally I do not believe that anything is the result of anything else, and if we happen to have a large brain coinciding with our increased consciousness then both are a reflection of the other, neither is causal. If we're being tangible about it, though, you could either say that large consciousness is the result of a large brain, or that a large brain is a result of large consciousness. Which would you choose? It would be a subjective choice because logically neither is truer than the other. I think, though, we would tend to choose the brain being the cause and consciousness being the effect, simply because the brain is a physical measurable thing. For us small entities, within the whole, looking out at the world around us, we see only expansion. For the whole, looking in on us small entities, it seems only contraction. Both are true. Being human beings, looking out on the world, we tend to look AT the brain, and seeing nothing beyond it we conclude it to be the original source. If we flipped paradigm to one of intangible truth, though, which would allow both outlooks to be true and complementary, we'd see not only that the mind is causal to the brain, but that both are a reflection of each other. With astrology for example, people /usually/ say that the position of planets and the sun influences us - has a causal effect on us. However, that is not so. The reason it is possible for it TO have an effect is due to its acausal relationship with us - thus it is a reflection of us and we a reflection of it. BA> were /supposed/ to evolve into ? How can we tell when another life BA> form is conscious rather than just an organism running some sort of BA> "program". We human beings are organisms running programs too you know. The only ADDITION is that part of our design is the ability to return to our creator through self realisation. Unfortuantely this added ability tends to overshadow the design still inherant in what happens to us, thus we tend to think we're totally in control. BA> It seems to me that all life forms do the same basic things BA> that we do except on a more basic level IYSWIM. Yes, they do. Humans do what the universe does, only on a smaller level. BA> Our minds seem to have BA> more "IF / THEN" type decisions going on all the time. I might add that the mind does NOT work using language. Just because you might take your thoughts to a level of conversation that does not mean you think in words, or that you have "if then" thoughts. Take away the conversion to language and we're really no different to any other creature. The only thing which sets man apart from all over life forms is his ability to realise his true self. If you neglect that ability, you are nothing better than an animal. BA> Is it because BA> of this that we are the most conscious of all the species on this BA> planet ? It depends what you call conscious. I would say that when you approach the final stages of self realisation you start to place yourself in the hands of God, in nature's arms. All the rest of nature already is doing this! So in a way we are less perfect than all over life forms, but this imperfection allows us to realise our perfect state. Intelligence doesn't necessarily equate with real knowlege or progress. In the end, God is single and infinite, in which you need no knowledge or intelligence to understand. In a sense, a tramp is more intelligent than God, although of course God is all things. BA> When our brain dies, this "side effect" dies with it. Nothing of the sort. What you're saying is that when the thing used to measure SOME effects of consciousness is removed, you no longer can measure it, hense you fling yourself to the other extreme and say that the consciousness now no longer exists. This is false. Let me put it quite simply. For a living human being you have a physical body, and some kind of `life' thing which determines that the body isn't dead. When the body dies, all that's happened is that the `life' thing is removed from the body. This does NOT mean it is removed from existence, especially not as you cannot truly measure this `soul' in a physical way. The difference between a living person and a dead person is that the living person has awareness. As awareness appears to go away when the body dies, or rather the body dies as the awareness goes away, is it not safe to say that the awareness is simple no longer attatched? As we ARE our awareness, thus we are eternal. BA> We don't go to BA> any "afterlife". We most certainly do. The problem is this... The physical world is an extreme end of a scale. There is a scale going from infinity down to what we call finity - the physcalness of this world. If you ONLY live in the physical end of the scale, you only experience the physical end, normally. Because it depicts so clearly the largest extreme of `solid reality', we think that as soon as that physicality is taken away there will be none left for there to be another place to exist. This is flawed. Just because you take away a huge chunk of physicality when you die, it does not work in a tangible way. You have to have a different paradigm to understand this properly. If you're in a paradigm where tangibility means truth, which is the usual paradigm to be in nowadays, you make measurements and you have quantities of things. Thus, if you put together all the physical world you know of and call it a whole, having never recalled an experience beyond it, you say that `this' is all there is. Thus you attribute pretty much 100% to the amount of physicalness there is here. So what's left for `there'? Nothing. So you conclude there is nothing beyond death. However, the only reason you say that the physical world is the whole is because you've not experienced anything beyond it, or what you can call `beyond it'. If you flip to a paradigm of intangible truth, in which infinity is the whole truth, you see that everything here is relative. When someone dies they seem to pop out of existence basically. Thus you'd normally conclude that they have subtracted all the existence possible and thus no longer exist. But in realising that the physical world is the END OF A SCALE, and not the whole scale, you also realise that there are different levels of existence and that you will go to one. Just because you cannot physically measure these other places you deduce that they aren't there. Just because you can't measure God it doesn't mean he isn't there. God, being infinite, can only be proven if you can show that he is infinite. In failing to supply proof of God, you thus prove him, for lack of proof is found where things are infinite. Just because you cannot physically measure anything beyond what you experience or have been experiencing here in the physical, that does not qualify you to make judgements of things which are beyond the physical world. Far from it. When someone dies you throw away all the evidence you have experienced and recall of what existence means - ie physical life. Thus you think hey, they're no longer alive. Wrong. They are alive, just not physically. All that is removed at death is the physical aspect. The beingness aspect stays. When you are alive, there are two things going on. First, you are physical. Second, you exist, you be, you are. When you die, you stop perceiving the physical. This does not mean you stop perceiving because perception is made possible by way of the beingness part of things. Thus, you must at least `BE' when you are physically dead. As the physical is only one end of a scale, it would be safe to assume that there are many other levels of `physicality', and that you will be in one of them when you venture towards the other end. BA> The "I" dies. No. If the world is purely physical, it is one thing, a tangible *limited* continuum. As such, it is one thing. Being one thing, it is NOT possible for there to be contrast. Thus there could not possibly be a physical apparatus looking at a physical thing and knowing that it's there. You MUST have distance in order to perceive. Thus, to perceive the physical world, the thing doing the perceiving must NOT be physical. If it were, it simply would not be able to perceive because ITS composition would be identical with the thing it were looking at. Thus it would BE all things and hense no awareness of partiality. Thus, the `I' does NOT die when the physical level dies, because the `I' is not and cannot be physical. BA> It's hard to understand "nothingness" There is no such thing as nothingness. Just because God is indifferent that does not mean he doesn't have within himself every single emotion and feeling and fallacy and creation which exists anywhere and everywhere. Just because he is infinite, that does NOT mean he doesn't love or care. In fact, he cares for us far more than we care for him. Such attraction attracts us to him perpetually, depicted as entropy here - energy returning to its creator. Why is it that when energy merges with the single energy pool, it ceases to exist as a form? Because it is one thing. Thus if the `I' and the physical world were one thing there would be no existence of the `I'. BA> now, but it doesn't matter because we won't be "there" to have to BA> understand it IYSWIM. When you die, you simultaneously detatch from physicality. Thus ANY judgements you made in the physical world are no longer valid because the place you're in is very different. BA> Any comments on these ? Yea. If the things you're basing truth on is tangibility, a limit, an absolute (not the same as infinite), or any kind of `thing', you CANNOT prove any kind of infinity concept. This includes life beyond the limits of the limit, perception beyond the limits of the limit (the brain), etc... If you start looking at things using tools of limitation and categorisation, you simply CANNOT see how something can exist beyond those limits. If you put on rose-tinted glasses and walk around, the world becomes a rose colour - you cannot properly see any of the colours because they are filtered out by the basis of your perception. Thus, if you're basing ANYTHING on tangible truth of any kind, you CANNOT prove God, life after death, consciousness beyond the brain, consciousness beyond biology, etc... With tangible truth you immediately introduce limits, limits which cannot be gone beyond. Thus, you cannot look beyond the limits of the brain, beyond physical evidence, beyond what you can categorise and label, nothing beyond. A beyond just doesn't come into it. There's no point even discussing a beyond if you're going to base your deductions on a paradigm of limitation - ie tangibility. Jumping to a paradigm of intangible truth, which is based on the WHOLE truth and nothing but the truth - infinity, you immediately find the significance of a `beyond', thus allowing you to postulate a beyond death, a beyond the brain, a beyond human consciousness, and a beyond physical existence. Regards, Paul. Fidonet 2:251/31.8 PsychoNet 1080:108/0.4 IncarNet 153:250/8.4 --- * Origin: Delirious BBS, Hants. (2:251/31.8)