Slimelite BBS

Re: Language and culture

Back to APRIL

From Andrew Grillet · 1996-04-10 04:10 · #76409 in APRIL

In reply to Language and culture by Ray Girvan

 -=> On 06 Apr 96  05:51:42 Ray Girvan said to Andrew Grillet <=-

 RG> As far as the practical everyday implications of using
 RG> the same word "they" for singular as for plural, we're
 RG> perfectly comfortable with other double-purpose words
 RG> (for instance, "you").  

My point about legal eagleas was that they want to be seen to live
by the rules to impress, and that is why they do not like using the
plural. This spins off onto others that cohabit with legals.

There is a problem with 'you' - in my family we say 'you-plural'
when a statement is directed at more than one person, and I
say 'you-collectively' to non-family members in the same 
situation. Southern Americans say 'you-all'. Itsa major defect in
the english language.

 RG> (I suspect it's one of
 RG> those usages that people like Dryden suddenly and
 RG> arbitrarily defined as wrong in the 18th century).
 
A fairly safe bet.

 RG> Quite.  But the friend I asked, Felix Grant, is well aware
 RG> of that (one of his interests is the under-rated Arabic
 RG> contribution to mathematics).

Glad to know there are some promoting this cause.
 
 AG> ... this is because English HAS got rules about the
 AG> uses of vowel sounds and stress in various parts of
 AG> speech which are 'undocumented'.

 RG> Depends where you look.  There's a lot of difference
 RG> between English as documented linguistically, and the
 RG> kind of simplistic rules that used to turn up in grammar
 RG> books.

Hooray for voiced labial frictives :-)

Andrew

 
... You gotta know when to code 'em, know when to modem....
--- Blue Wave/Max v2.12 OS/2 [NR]
 * Origin: Me/2 <Meet-You> (2:254/259)