Slimelite BBS

Re: What Science Cannot

Back to APRIL

From Andrew Grillet · 1996-04-06 02:09 · #76375 in APRIL

In reply to What Science Cannot by Alex Macphee

 -=> On 01 Apr 96  22:30:52 Alex Macphee said to Andrew Grillet <=-

Hi Alex,

 AG> The welfare state is colapsing because the government has only about two
 AG> brain cells between them

 AM> Two brain cells?  When does the second one get switched on, then?
 When deciding their next pay increase:

...Government of the dick-heads, by the slease-balls for the scum-bags :-)

 AM> Scientists are human beings, not serene god-like aliens.  They live in
 AM> the same world we do, and in the same political, social, industrial
 AM> and military organisations.  They share the same responsibilities as
 AM> everyone else for their work.

 AG> And with no more idea what there work will be used for than anyone else.
 AG> The baker does not know if his bread will go to feed serial killers either,

 AM> The baker baking bread can reasonably assume that it's primary
 AM> function is for eating.  The team involved in designing and building
 AM> atomic bombs cannot pretend to be unaware of its function as a killing
 AM> machine.
 The team making bombs are engineers and technicians. Scientists doing the
 science were Einstein, Huysenberg, Planc - their work applies equally to
 cancer cures and space travel.

 AM> The people who were killed by the last two atom bombs can
 AM> have the dubious reassurance of knowing that the bombs that tore them
 AM> apart and burned them into the rocks were scientifically designed
 AM> by real scientists to do just that.

 AG> And the millions of Japanese soldiers who were not sent to their deaths
 AG> as a result of the end of the war have these same scientists to thank.
 AG> Not to mention a vast number of Japanese and Allied civilians.

 AM> This is untrue.  Japan was already signalling frantically that she
 AM> wanted terms for surrender.

AFAIAA to this day it is uncertain whether those wanting to surrender
could have achieved a surrender. There were powerful people in Japan
who were against a surrender.

 The US had already invaded Okinawa, Japan
 AM> had been defeated at India, and the German and Italian armies had
 AM> surrendered.

Japan was not an ally of Germany and Italy just because it was against
the allies.

 AM> The operational decisions are military, but that does not mean
 AM> that neither science nor scientists are freed from any culpability or
 AM> responsibility for their handiwork.

 AG> In the case of the WW2 A-bomb, the scientists explicitly stated they
 AG> weanted the bomb to be 'demonstrated' on an uninhabited island.

 AM> Richard Feynmann, who worked on the project, knew perfectly well what
 AM> he and Oppenheimer and his other colleagues were working on.

And argues AGAINST dropping it on people, having a good understanding of
the consequences. The politicians/military were looking from a different
angle, which included a great measure of scepicism about the claims
of what the bomb could do, and indeed whether it was going to do anything.

We never heard of most of the 'mad scientist schemes' developed in the
war that didn't make it, either because they were too crackpot, or because
the military chose not to fund them adequately, and then blamed the
development team for failing to meet targets. The military knows that
it spends loads of defence bucks on R&D which yields a spit in a bucket
when the delivery date arrives. They have no ability whatever to know
whats a good idea till after it goes bang.

 AG> The military were concerned that the demonstation might not go well,
 AG> and they'd be in a worse military position than with no demonstation
 AG> (secret weapon is hoax headlines over world press). IE they did not
 AG> really believe in the A-bomb.

 AM> A demonstration that 'failed' on the targetted cities would have been
 AM> militarily 'worse' than a failed desert island test!

No - it would have been assumed to have been coventional weapons that
failed in the absense of any preceding drum-roll.

Its well documented that the decision was taken on these grounds.
Given that these are the official records which were secret at the time,
classified for 30 years, I think they are likely to be genuine.

Andrew


... Nothing so absurd can be said, that some philosopher has not said it.
--- Blue Wave/Max v2.12 OS/2 [NR]
 * Origin: Me/2 <Meet-You> (2:254/259)