Slimelite BBS

What Science Cannot

Back to APRIL

From Alex Macphee · 1996-04-02 04:30 · #76366 in APRIL

Hello Andrew,

[Andrew Grillet to Alex Macphee, Mar 15 '96]

AG> The welfare state is colapsing because the government has only about two
AG> brain cells between them

Two brain cells?  When does the second one get switched on, then?

 AM> Scientists are human beings, not serene god-like aliens.  They live in
 AM> the same world we do, and in the same political, social, industrial
 AM> and military organisations.  They share the same responsibilities as
 AM> everyone else for their work.

AG> And with no more idea what there work will be used for than anyone else.
AG> The baker does not know if his bread will go to feed serial killers either,
AG> but he doesn't get any hassle for baking bread.

The baker baking bread can reasonably assume that it's primary
function is for eating.  The team involved in designing and building
atomic bombs cannot pretend to be unaware of its function as a killing
machine.  That a baker may bake bread for a serial killer is
accidental.  That an atom bomb is made to kill by the thousand is not
accidental.

 AM> The people who were killed by the last two atom bombs can
 AM> have the dubious reassurance of knowing that the bombs that tore them
 AM> apart and burned them into the rocks were scientifically designed
 AM> by real scientists to do just that.

AG> And the millions of Japanese soldiers who were not sent to their deaths
AG> as a result of the end of the war have these same scientists to thank.
AG> Not to mention a vast number of Japanese and Allied civilians.

This is untrue.  Japan was already signalling frantically that she
wanted terms for surrender. The US had already invaded Okinawa, Japan had
been defeated at India, and the German and Italian armies had
surrendered. As far as saving vast numbers of Japanese civilians is
concerned, there are Japanese dying of it even today.  It is more than
possible that surrender terms were delayed in order to expedite the
test bombing of Japan. The two cities chosen, Hiroshima and Nagasaki,
were chosen to test two different bomb types, one uranium and one
plutonium.  The two cities chosen were kept free throughout the war
from all conventional bombing raids, making it simpler to assess
the damage and blast effects of different types of atomic bombing without the
complication of factoring out damage caused by conventional warheads.
Winston Churchill, that old warmonger, himself condemned the nuclear
bombings.

AG> I firmly believe WW3 was prevented by TV, not the bomb. It shows us the
AG> enemy are people like us. I say send TVs to Bosnia and Rwanda.

Naive optimism. Truth is the first casualty of war, and the lead-up to war.

 AM> Yes. The operational decisions are military, but that does not mean
 AM> that neither science nor scientists are freed from any culpability or
 AM> responsibility for their handiwork.

AG> In the case of the WW2 A-bomb, the scientists explicitly stated they
AG> weanted the bomb to be 'demonstrated' on an uninhabited island.

Richard Feynmann, who worked on the project, knew perfectly well what
he and Oppenheimer and his other colleagues were working on.

AG> The military were concerned that the demonstation might not go well,
AG> and they'd be in a worse military position than with no demonstation
AG> (secret weapon is hoax headlines over world press). IE they did not
AG> really believe in the A-bomb.

A demonstration that 'failed' on the targetted cities would have been
militarily 'worse' than a failed desert island test!



-Alex

--- MsgPost 1.1
 * Origin: Voyager (01483 751324) (2:440/31)