From Paul West · 1996-04-06 04:40 · #74369 in AMIGA_MAGS
In reply to Restrict Your Offerings by Howard Ambler
On 31-Mar-96, I literally ran into Fingers McHoward Ambler! In the chaotic tangle, you pickpocketed my Restrict Your Offerings. "Hey, Howard!", I said! [B^} HA> Don't mind if I keep this reply short, but I'd be contradicting myself HA> if I wrote an "essay" to you when I encourage people to keep it short HA> and relevant. All the same that places a restriction on you so nothing much is gained. HA> Sorry, I was merely refering to the world of cyberspace which is not HA> real and in which we reside for the purposes of electronic HA> conversation. This HA> has no relevance at all - as you say because there are no "real" HA> effects from writing e-mails other than those gained from the missives HA> themselves. Ah I see. Yep. PW>> Unfortunately that is true. But that's only because the life they're PW>> having to lead is one build around the economy, hense having to serve PW>> it rather than being served by it. HA> As opposed to what? Well. There is two definitions of `to serve'. One is the healthy definition in which the government is there to serve us and ONLY serve us and it wants to do it no matter what. The other is that the government becomes like a SERVICE and we have to pay it things and give stuff back to it. A kind of mutual service - except it seems to look more like a one-sides affair at the moment. You may notice that the change from a serving government to a mutual service government is the `fulfillment' of proper government, which is anothe sign of the end-times. HA> I'd disagree, although not everything you write is of that nature it HA> just tends to err on the philosophical side, hence the length of your HA> missives is rather long and difficult to read unless you have a couple HA> of hours handy to digest the concepts. Interesting. I was just told in the dreams echo that my writing is all sorts of nice things :) HA> No, its simply that I don't think it exists and therefore to talk HA> about it when I know nothing and have no belief in it, means I would HA> be poorly qualified to give an informed opinion. Where's this that sais you have to be `qualified' to give an informed opinion. I didn't ask for an informed opinion, I asked for your opinion. I wanted it from you, not anyone else, thus it doesn't need be informed. My interest in you was the main feature of the question. HA> Ok, but on the terms I am talking about - science is an understanding HA> tool which helps people to come to terms with what they consider HA> paranormal. I disagree. Science is tangible tool which attempts to explain the untangible. Hense if the paranormal doesn't fit into the spectrum of tangibility then it gets converted to tangibility, or is said to be false. HA> If you consider things to be less paranormal/magickal as HA> a result of it being brought into the realms of something we can HA> understand then there must be a dividing line between that which we do HA> not understand and that which we can explain scientifically. There is no such deviding line. The line is that science can only ever approximately understand anything, and therefore anything it `explains' is over the line. HA> Of course, scientists assume methods so would not make a philosophical HA> argument without firm basis in fact. True. Then again philosphy is also dependant upon tangible truth just like science, is it not? The things I'm saying aren't based on tangible truth, and thus is not philosophy. PW>> There's no guessing coming into it. The ability to guess went out the PW>> window with the linear concept. HA> Sorry to be pedantic but you have contridicated yourself here:- GUESS HA> - "To form an opinion of with little or no consideration of the HA> facts". HA> Therefore without facts you assume the realm of guesswork. Your definition is correct. By guess I meant that to even have the ability to guess - that ability went out the window when I threw aside linearality. You need linearality, and hense in an inter-related way you also need partiality, in order to be an individal in order to guess. Thus because I said we had let go of linearality we also let go of guesswork and hense whatever I was saying was undenyable, there could be no guessing involved. HA> Again, this would need a theolgian to comment - I can't comment being HA> an atheist, my stand point comes from a humanist point of view so I HA> see God's work no-where rather the work of the human race as a species HA> with all its traditions and cruelties. That's a humanist? Hmm. HA> Very true in some respects but as someone with a completely open mind HA> I would just argue that just because I hold one point of view it does HA> not mean that I see everything through the standards that I set HA> myself. What I would say is that is everyone adopted your approach to HA> writing in this echo then 50% of people would just leave for some more HA> relevant and factual discussion of the paranormal. Writing is neither here nor there. Break it down further. I have a message, something to communicate. Wether I do it by writing or art or poetry or whatever, that's just the way to express it. Unfortunately writing isn't one of the best mediums to express it, but it's one where I have access to a lot of people. I am not saying to propogate my style of writing - but WHAT I am writing about. PW>> There's always at least two ways of looking at things. You seem to PW>> have found one of them. HA> And you the other....... That's not what I meant. I have found BOTH viewpoints, you have found only one (it seems). Regards, Paul. Fidonet 2:254/284.4 PsychoNet 1080:108/0.4 IncarNet 153:250/8.4 --- * Origin: Psychonautica BBS, London. (2:254/284.4)