Slimelite BBS

Restrict Your Offerings

Back to AMIGA_MAGS

From Howard Ambler · 1996-04-01 02:52 · #74155 in AMIGA_MAGS

Through the mists of time came Paul West bringing 
a message about Restrict Your Offerings to Howard Ambler 
 
 Hiya Paul,

Don't mind if I keep this reply short, but I'd be contradicting myself if
I wrote an "essay" to you when I encourage people to keep it short and
relevant.

 HA>> That REALLY is taking the philosophical viewpoint  -unfortunately in
 HA>> the real world that theory would be simply laughed at as nearly

 PW> As you call it the real world, I presume you are depending on an unreal
 PW> world existing somewhere. Care to elaborate on it? As the real world
 PW> isn't all of the possible world, of course there wouldbe things like
 PW> laughter at it.

Sorry, I was merely refering to the world of cyberspace which is not real
and in which we reside for the purposes of electronic conversation.  This
has no relevance at all - as you say because there are no "real" effects
from writing e-mails other than those gained from the missives themselves.

 HA>> everyone depends on FACTS to get them through day to day life.

 PW> Unfortunately that is true. But that's only because the life they're
 PW> having to lead is one build around the economy, hense having to serve it
 PW> rather than being served by it.

As opposed to what?

 HA>> FACTs are what stops us from blowing ourselves up when the philosophy
 HA>> and theory is WRONG.

 PW> Then perhaps you're calling my stuff philosophical when it's not
 PW> because I'm not postulating a theory, I'm simply outlining an undeniable
 PW> truth.

I'd disagree, although not everything you write is of that nature it just
tends to err on the philosophical side, hence the length of your missives is
rather long and difficult to read unless you have a couple of hours handy to
digest the concepts.

 HA>> Sorry can't comment on that as I'm an atheist so for me heaven doesn't
 HA>> exist. ;-(

 PW> Okay. So if heaven doesn't exist for you you cannot comment on it?
 PW> Doesn't this mean that there is a certain inherant physics going on? Why
 PW> is the lack of beleif in heaven accompanied by the inability to talk
 PW> about it? Isn't that inherant resonance?

No, its simply that I don't think it exists and therefore to talk about it
when I know nothing and have no belief in it, means I would be poorly
qualified to give an informed opinion.

 PW> True, but before science even started the world still ticked over,
 PW> birds still have their food provided, everything worked just fine on its
 PW> own. Obviously as science has gobbled up the mystery it has always left
 PW> a certain amount unknown, and that ever decreasing marjin is what's
 PW> generally thought to be the unexplained, or paranormal. That doesn't
 PW> mean, however, that just because science explains something it suddenly
 PW> stops being precicely what it was before. If a zulu tribe thought that
 PW> television was the face of God, that's what it IS. IF you explain to
 PW> them that it is a television, that is a second description of it. Why
 PW> should it totally wipe out the previous one? IT's in science's nature to
 PW> wipe out previous descriptions, and that's why everything is still just
 PW> as paranormal and magickal as it ever was.

Ok, but on the terms I am talking about - science is an understanding tool
which helps people to come to terms with what they consider paranormal.  If
you consider things to be less paranormal/magickal as a result of it being
brought into the realms of something we can understand then there must be a
dividing line between that which we do not understand and that which we can
explain scientifically.  Perhaps the term "paranormal" is not correct here
as many things are not considered paranormal which are beyond science at
this time - paranormal is associated with magickal arts and that which we
may consider weird rather than that which we do not yet know anything about.

 PW>>> I thought I was a logical thinker.
 HA>> Logical but not sientific I can safely say! :-)

 PW> There's a difference?

Of course, scientists assume methods so would not make a philosophical
argument without firm basis in fact.

 PW> [Eternally existing objects]
 HA>> So are you saying that there IS no correct state in which to place
 HA>> yourself i.e. rather than commiting yourself to making the most of your
 HA>> short time on Earth  by experiencing factual events like visiting crop
 HA>> circles and investigating UFO experiences you would rather have a BEST
 HA>> guess

 PW> There's no guessing coming into it. The ability to guess went out the
 PW> window with the linear concept.

Sorry to be pedantic but you have contridicated yourself here:- GUESS - "To
form an opinion of with little or no consideration of the facts".

Therefore without facts you assume the realm of guesswork.

 PW> Have you ever looked for God? I'm don't mean to sound religious here,
 PW> but have you ever like looked around to see if you can see God doing
 PW> something which doesn't happen by normally accepted methods? Well, if
 PW> you look hard enough you can see God all over the place. Why? Because he
 PW> IS all over the place. If I did this, would you come back and say that I
 PW> only saw what I wanted to see, or I saw it because that's what I was
 PW> looking for?

Again, this would need a theolgian to comment - I can't comment being an
atheist, my stand point comes from a humanist  point of view so I see God's
work no-where rather the work of the human race as a species with all its
traditions and cruelties.

 PW> Seeing as there is this inherancy, don't you wonder WHY it is that you
 PW> perceive my to be doing the things you postulated above? Rather than
 PW> just see me doing those things, don't you wonder why or how you see
 PW> those things? It is said that you see what you are, IOW if you are a
 PW> child you see everyone else as being children, just as if you are adult
 PW> you tend to look at everyone else in an adult way. It's inherant. So
 PW> maybe there is some inherancy in what you're seeing, rather than what's
 PW> there?

Very true in some respects but as someone with a completely open mind I
would just argue that just because I hold one point of view it does not mean
that I see everything through the standards that I set myself.  What I would
say is that is everyone adopted your approach to writing in this echo then
50% of people would just leave for some more relevant and factual discussion
of the paranormal.

 PW> I promise I'm not doing anything quite so grandios as you suggest. In
 PW> infinity you can find any amount of infinite truth by starting
 PW> anywhere. So why start with facts, evidence, UFO's, crop circles, etc?

Again it comes down to realism and human experience - if we were all gods or
lived in another dimension we'd have all the answers and wouldn't care about
facts or research but unforntunattely we are not so we have to battle on -
the poor sods we are with gathering facts and coming to REAL conclusions
about the world in which we live.  I think context best describes it (the
human lifetime)

 PW> There's always at least two ways of looking at things. You seem to have
 PW> found one of them.

And you the other.......

Ta ta

UBCU

|-|<>\X/ar|}  +-Internet: 93015501@cs3.brookes.ac.uk -+ 
              +-UFONET  405:110/24.8 -+

... Every program has at least one bug and one unnecessary instruction
       - therefore, every program can be reduced to one instruction that
       doesn't work.
--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
 * Origin: -+- Lemming Haven PLC, pres d'Oxford  -+- (2:252/18.14)