Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-14 01:03 · #74125 in PRATCHETT

Hi Mark,

[Re: Dr Who trailer]

 GM> Was it any good? or was it just a lot of pretty FX?

MS> You seem to be quite obsessed with all this "pretty FX" business!
MS> Do you go and see a film and just sit there passing judgement on
MS> the FX or summat?

No. I go to see a film to be entertained. I also prefer to be intellectually
stimulated if it is appropriate to the film. I just don't like being
expected to think that a film is great because there are lots of effects to
cover up the fact that there is no plot.

[Re: The Prisoner remake]

MS> True, they'd probably put too many FX in.

I think you're probably being slightly sarcastic there or just joking, but I
think you're right! The original series got away with hardly any (apart from
a couple of lava lamps and a weather balloon!).

Why should a remake have special effects, just because they can be done now?

[Re: Johnny Mnemonic]

 GM> Ok, they had to change bits around to put it on the screen (and for
 GM> copyright reasons)...

MS> "Copyright reasons" has nothing to do with it. The publisher would
MS> have sold complete film rights -- they wouldn't say, "Well, we
MS> can't do this because it's already copyrighted in the book."

Yes, but someone else had already bought the rights to Neuromancer and,
therefore, the copyright on the character of Molly.

 GM> but why on earth did he let them the ridiculous"my head's going to
 GM> explode if I don't get rid of this information" plot

MS> Because more people would flock to see that version of JM than a
MS> version more faithful to Gibbo's orginal story. Makes sense.

Makes a terrible film! And how do you *know* that the original story
wouldn't have been a cinema success?

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)