Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-14 00:54 · #74124 in PRATCHETT

Hi Mark,

[Re: news]

MS> Well, I could post as much or as little as possible. I didn't know
MS> what everyone's general level of awareness was as far as sci-fi
MS> productions are concerned. If no-one's heard about 'Powder' and
MS> 'Twister' then they're a bit behind the times!

Well, I can't speak for anyone else, but, yes, I'm rather out of touch at
the moment, being too busy with other stuff (including Fido). In fact, if
you, via Fido could keep me up to date I'd be very grateful!

[Re: Powder and Twister]

Hmm, sounds interesting, thanks.

[Re: Star Wars]

 GM> Audience expectations, or the film studios' opinions of what the
 GM> public want to see?

MS> It's a double-edged sword though -- audiences and the studios can both
MS> share the blame. I mean, take something like 'Strange Days'.  The best
MS> sci-fi film we've had since 'The Abyss' and no-one's going to see it.

Hmm, yes, I take your point. I suppose that's been true throught, though,
some of the best films flop, yet the dross can flourish.

MS> you can't blame the production studios for not taking risks.

I suppose not. Daft though, isn't it?

 MS>> It wasn't until the likes of '2001' and 'Blade Runner' that the sci-fi
 MS>> film found a proper cinematic foothold.

 GM> Why can't we have more 2001's and Blade Runner's?

MS> So, why the lack of classics? Well, the sci-fi genre is still
MS> considered a bit of a 'fringe' job.

Unfortunately very true, but I've made my feelings clear on that particular
subject more than once in here!

MS> the general movie-going public tend to be a bit evasive when it comes to
MS> sci-fi movies. So, if the production companies don't see anyone
MS> coming to see their extravagant, cerebral sci-fi movies, then why
MS> should they risk raking out the readies for further non-events?

But the same can be said for some of the big "action" movies such as
Stargate, Waterworld and so on. The problem is that the big money flops
send shockwaves through the industry (indeed they have brought down more
than one production company) which makes the others less willing to take the
chances on making others.

MS> You watch, when the new SW movie is released within the next few years,
MS> we'll see a glut of sci-fi movies that will pull in the crowds.

Of course, as every other production company jumps on to the bandwagon
trying to cash in on the public's gullibility, hoping they'll think "well,
if SW IV (hang on, that was a computer game, wasn't it?!) was so great this
one will be too".

MS> It worked in the case of 'Blade Runner'. If it wasn't for 'Star Wars',
MS> it probably wouldn't have been made.

Probably not. I guess we'll just have to keep on putting up with the dross
and the garbage and SF's bad image simply so we can sort out a few gems.

MS> [Simplifying movie plots]

 GM> it's a matter of whether there is anything else left once the plot has
 GM> been broken down to its elements.

MS> But 'Star Wars' was never intended to be a cerebral sci-fi movie.

True...

MS> You can't deny that 'Star Wars' is an incredible cinematic experience.

No, I don't, in fact I agree completely which is *why* I started this whole
thread off in the first place! (But see later)

MS> What George Lucas managed to do was create something that was as big a
MS> crowd-puller as the cheap & cheerful matinees, but with the epic feel of
MS> a David Lean movie. In doing so, he created the phenomenon of the summer
MS> blockbuster

But, again, is that a *benefit* to the SF film genre? I heard a comment that
Hollywood would prefer to risk $50,000,000 to make back $100,000,000 than to
risk $10,000,000 to make back $20,000,000.

This just panders to the "big spectacle audience pleaser", not to the less
profitable but better for the genre "cerebral" SF film.

MS> Can you name a sci-fi film predating 'Star Wars' that was a box office
MS> blitz, critically acclaimed and technically light years ahead of
MS> anything else? Nah! You can't! ;)

Yes I can: It took a little while to get there, but 2001 was.

[Re: Alien: a jazzed up monster hunt]

 GM> Yes, but there is more to it than that.

 GM> You also have the whole background of "the Corporation"... and the
 GM> the question (although it was never really addressed in the first film)
 GM> of where the Alien came from.

MS> An unresolved plot-thread! How did you cope? ;)

I managed, but I wasn't exactly pleased. There again, too much exposition of
this would have overloaded the first film. The problem is that it was never
really addressed in the second or third film either which *was* annoying.

MS> Yes, but these extra trappings aren't exactly exclusive sci-fi
MS> film devices.

Of course not, they are the trappings of *any* good film.

MS> What you're essentially saying is that 'Alien' was a more densely
MS> textured movie than we normally get.

Yes, and we should have more of them. 

[Re: You can break down *any* film in a similar fashion]

 GM> But if that is *all* there is to the story and the characters then,
 GM> IMO, they *are* invalidated.

MS> So you're saying that 'Star Wars' and 'ET' aren't good movies?

It depends what you mean by "good". If you mean popular and impressive, then
yes. If you mean well constructed and plotted with real characters, then the
answer has to be no.

MS> I think they're both brilliant. Perhaps you should stop thinking of
MS> them as sci-fi movies.

If I did that would make it worse because then they would have *no* saving
graces and would show up as the vapid things they are.

MS> If a movie has sci-fi trappings, then it should be assumed that it's
MS> trying to compete with 'Blade Runner' or '2001'.

Why? I never said that. Would you say that Blade Runner was trying to
compete with 2001? No?

I try to consider films on their own merits (if they have any).

 MS>> Give me the name of a decent pre-'Star Wars' sci-fi movie and I'll
 MS>> name you a decent post-'Star Wars' one.

 GM> Ok, try The Day the Earth Stood Still, Forbidden Planet, This Island
 GM> Earth, 2001, Phase IV and The Andromeda Strain.

MS> Le Dernier Combat, The Terminator, Robocop, The Abyss, Children of
MS> the Lost City and Strange Days. Could have mentioned Alien and
MS> Blade Runner too.

But did the first list *rely* on special effects? What are the characters
and plots like in the second? Has the definition of "decent" changed?

 GM> it has become too easy to put in flashy special effects where the
 GM> character and plot development ought to be.

MS> Same with other movies though, not just sci-fi.

Yes, but IMO it's prevalent in SF films (and films linked to the SF genre,
eg the Bond/ Schwarzennegger films).

 GM> Star Wars was such a quantum leap in FX that everyone jumped on the
 GM> band wagon forgetting to include characterisations or plotting.

MS> But sfx is just another tool in the film-maker's armoury.

"Another tool", yes, but not, as it seems to often be, the *only* tool.

 GM> yes, perhaps the initial posting was deliberately intended to be
 GM> controversial however I feel that the general principle of SF films
 GM> being a victim of their own FX still holds true.

MS> Yes, it does hold true, but I don't think there's any 'post Star
MS> Wars' or 'pre Star Wars' argument here. 'Star Wars' showed just
MS> what film technology could do

True. Actually you were right about this thread a while back, I didn't
really have "the courage of my convictions" when I was attacking Star Wars,
I had a general principle, but I decided that SW was a good target to shy at
to get people talking. Seems to have worked...! ;-)

[Re: City of Lost Children, Twelve Monkeys etc]

Thanks for the details...

MS> With films like that I can't see how you can claim there's no
MS> decent sci-fi around -- you're just not watching it!

You could well be right, I am a bit out of touch at the moment. Good job
there's someone around with his finger on the pulse...! ;-)

MS> Back to SW's 'negative' influence...

[Big cut!]

I've cut the rest of this because, frankly, it's going over old stuff again
and you've made your points very well.

Thanks for a great discussion.

 MS>> There's good stuff out there -- just go and look for it.

 GM> I'm looking...!

MS> Obviously not hard enough!

Maybe you're right. All I need now is the time to do it!

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)