Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-13 21:37 · #74120 in PRATCHETT

Hi Matthew,

[Re: Star Wars got a lot of new fans interested in SF...]

  GM> But *what sort* of SF did they get interested in? The glitzy big box
  GM> office spectacular SF with its big effects and small plots and two
  GM> dimensional characters or the *real* SF with depth and content?

MH> I find this kind of snobishness a bit anoying.  What is wrong with
MH> a bit of whiz bang every so often.

I don't consider it to be snobbishness, rather I consider it the reaction of
someone who has got past the "it has to look good" attitude and wants
*depth* and *subtlety* from their entertainment.

There is nothing *wrong* with "a bit of whizz bang every so often", but the
problem is that this is *all* we get most of the time!

Do you roleplay? When I started playing RPGs I was hooked on the "bigger
weapon, better armour, kill harder monsters, rolling more dice" attitude.

But then I learned how much more fun the *ROLE* playing was. It wasn't so
important to kill lots of things, it was how you dealt with the *situations*
and the characters that was important.

It is still fun, occasionally, to have a "dungeon bash" where you can take
your mind off the hook, but this sort of thing gets *extremely boring* if it
is all that you do.

I now find that I can have more fun playing a first level (or whatever)
character, surviving on his wits and *interacting* with people, than playing
any 43rd level Fighter/ Paladin/ Ranger/ Cleric/ Thief.

MH> I like to think that I am a *real* SF&F fan and I enjoy Star Wars
MH> because it is good /entertainment/.

Yes, it is good /entertainment/, but so is Eastenders according to 20
million people...

MH> That is why I enjoy SF&F, not because it has a high snob-value among
MH> certain people but because I like the adventure and ideas behind it.
MH> Yes Star Wars does have interesting ideas in it.

It does?? Please, tell me what they are, because all I can see it (from my
"snobbish viewpoint") is a whole load of standard Fantasy cliches stuck in a
SF setting.

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)