From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-13 21:29 · #74119 in PRATCHETT
Hi Matthew, GM> There *have* been SF films which haven't relied on flashy special GM> effects, eg 2001: A Space Odyssey where the effects were so good that GM> they could be ignored (for the most part). MH> Well, just to stir things up a bit And why not...? MH> I think that 2001 is a prime example of "all efects and no substance". MH> Five minutes of a space ship landing followed by 5 seconds of cardboard MH> acting doesn't add up to a good film in my books. In 2001, however, the effects are so good that for the majority of the film (excluding the Star Gate sequence, of course), you are (or, at least I was) not consciously thinking "wow, what great effects", they are so effective that you can ignore them and concentrate on what is going on. Now, whilst I agree that 2001 is slow and that the dialogue is trite, what is not generally appreciated is that it was *deliberately* made that way. 2001 is not a film where, within the first ten minutes you are told what the plot is going to be and, by the end, someone else has explained everything for the hard of thinking. 2001 is *supposed* to make you think, it is not a "passive" experience where you can just sit back and be spoon fed, it requires some active thought by the viewer. There are layers of subtlety in 2001 which aren't immediately obvious, especially if you expect to be told them. For instance the "five minutes of spacecraft landing followed by five seconds of cardboard acting" that you mention had a very deliberate purpose. Firstly the spacecraft: you have to remember that this was originally made when spaceflight was brand new, but, even so, it still holds some magic. Instead we see spaceflight with The Blue Danube, for gods' sake, playing in the background. The point is that, in the time this film is set spaceflight is *so* mundane and ordinary that you can sleep through it, you have stewardesses with the same fake smiles, cardboard "airline" (spaceline?) meals etc, everything that exists for airline passengers now. In the cockpit you have the pilots surrounded by masses of displays. In the space station you have a vapid lift attendant "here you are, sir", so much like the "have a nice day" expressions which are automatically trotted out by counter staff. You have computer generated check in system with a human receptionist whose only job is to point you to the right check in to use. Then we hear tannoy announcements like "A lady's cashmere sweater has been found...", we have Floyd talking to his daughter, but the person he wants to talk to isn't available, and finally we have a group of what must be pretty highly trained scientists exchanging banal conversation and avoiding answering questions. The whole point is that *NO ONE IS COMMUNICATING*!!! For gods' sake, the most human one of the whole lot is Dr Floyd's daughter!! This is something which carries on throughout the film, the BBC "interview" with Bowman and Poole where HAL is more human in his reponses, Bowman's "Open the pod bay doors, HAL" and HAL's reply "This conversation can serve no useful purpose", then Bowman disconnects HAL and HAL says that he is *afraid*! This is probably the most human response in the entire film! But if you just sit there and expect to be told what is going on you are going to miss *all* of this. *THIS* is the reason that I "attack" films and books (from another thread), because this has taught me to *think* about what is going on and *why* people are doing what they do. MH> I will admit that it is a while since I saw the film, I found it MH> so dull the first time that a have never watched it since. Might I recommend that you give it another try in the light of my above comments? Don't just *look* at the film, try to *see* what is going on. The only problem is, of course, that 2001 was made to be a "big screen" experience and a lot of the impact is lost when it is squeezed onto a small screen, even if it is shown in "widescreen" instead of "pan and scan", but, even so, you can still appreciate it if you try. Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)