From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-13 01:12 · #74032 in PRATCHETT
Hi Jayne, [Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good] GM> Yes, they made use of the technology, but did they make *good* use of it? GM> Wouldn't Star Wars have been better if there *had* been a plot and the GM> characters weren't two dimensional? JJ> I think they made good use of it. I also think that Star Wars had JJ> a great plot, and good characters. "A great plot"?? Are you *kidding*? The plot was a science fiction update of the old Fantasy cliche of "Adopted farm boy learns he is actually the son of a great hero, has a destiny and rescues princess from evil wizard's tower"! The characterisations, too, were right out of the cliche book. GM> don't we, the audience, have a right to expect better than mass market GM> mind candy? JJ> Of course we do! But there's always going to be films that are all hype JJ> and little else. Films like Judge Dredd, Batman and the awful Mutant JJ> Turtles & Mario Brothers are relying more I think on the popular JJ> character concept than on special effects. I agree about all of these except Batman. Also Dredd didn't *rely* on being a popular character, the SF fans who read 2000 AD are only a very small part of the movie watching public. JJ> I watched about 30 minutes of Batman and turned the telly over because JJ> I was bored out of my skull! IMO the first Batman film was actually quite good. Although it went for a pretty standard "Superhero" plot, the characterisations were excellent (and Jack Nicholson's overacting is almost always worth a look!) Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)