Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-13 01:13 · #74031 in PRATCHETT

Hi Quentin,

[Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good]

QS> Absolutely disagree: if you want to tarnish anything with that, then the
QS> culprit must be 2001

GM> .. but *why*? There's no point in putting something like this if
GM> you're not going to back it up with reasons.

QS> I saw no point in reposting your reasons.

Eh? I'm not sure I follow this unless your opinion is that "2001 has
actually done more harm..."

GM> Why do you consider that 2001 did harm to the SF genre?

QS> I don't believe it did. It's just that it was the first.

So *why* do you disagree that Star Wars has done harm...? Do you disagree
with *every* one of my points? If so, why?

GM> GM> Close Encounters: "Just because you feel like a misfit doesn't
GM> GM> mean that you can't be special" feel good plot.
GM>
GM> The hero, Roy Neary, is a bit of a wimp, doesn't relate to his
GM> family, is a basic nobody, but he manages to succeed in getting on
GM> the alien ship.

QS> He was invited AFAIR.

Yes, but that's like the dream of winning the lottery. You know,
intellectually, that it *isn't* going to be you, but that doesn't stop you
dreaming about it, does it? (Assuming you play, of course!)

In the same way Neary is a nobody until the alien ships come along and say
"It's *you*!"

GM> GM> Terminator 2: a chase movie with tons of pretty effects.
GM>
GM> QS> BTW I note that you don't mention T1
GM>
GM> Ok, Terminator was cheap, but I did say "practically every"...

QS> The holes appear. :}

Fine, so if there are holes, point them out! We are trying to have a debate!

GM> Also T1 didn't exactly bother with much of a plot (it was a padded out
GM> short story) and, again, the characters didn't have much depth.

QS> I think that they had more than was necessary. Part of the plot
QS> was the robot's gaining of character.

Eh? That was T2 where the robot gained "character". In Terminator it had no
character, it just kept coming and attacking.


[Re: films relying on effects and sets to try to conceal the fact that the
characters are two dimensional and the plots are simple]

GM> QS> While many films, fit your bill, there are many that don't.

GM> So which films do you think don't?

QS> Wargames for one.

Wargames? Teenage computer nerd hacks into defence computer and nearly
destroys the world? Where is the depth to the characters? Where is the
complexity of the plot?

The film basically panders to technophobia and that's it.

GM> QS> Films like The Black Hole are good counter-examples (Maximillian
GM> QS> being a QS> very believable 'different' villain),

GM> Eh? Maximillian wasn't anything special AIR, he was basically an
GM> archetypal mad scientist.

QS> Max was one of the robots, not the scientist.

Ah, yes, I remember now. But, there again, he wasn't exactly the villain,
was he? Just an updated version of the mad scientist's assistant.

GM> And Jurassic Park?? What was that if not a big budget FX fest?

QS> Jaws on land.

So you're saying that *JAWS* has a deep plot and "realistic" chararcters?
Ok, the characterisations aren't too bad, but what plot...?

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)