From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-11 03:12 · #74025 in PRATCHETT
Hi Robert, Welcome to the echo! [Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good] GM> ever since Star Wars came out, practically every SF film has been a big GM> budget special effects fest with big sets, big names), but minimal GM> attention being paid to either plots or characterisations. RL> Isn't the problem that SciFi falls into two categories - that which RL> bravely attempts to predict our possible futures (either near or far), RL> and that which offers the possibility of escape from the present. Hmm, I think that's almost a topic in itself! ;-) I see what you're saying, but like the discussion a couple of months ago (which you probably missed) about whether Horror was On Topic in here (eg for things such as The Day of the Triffids), SF isn't that easy to tie down. After all, where would you put Star Trek? Pure escapism or a possible future? What about Blade Runner? A dark future or a moral tale? The Andromeda Strain: a taut thriller or a warning about man dabbling in what he was not meant to know? Yes, there are some parts of SF which are clearly in one camp or the other, but there are so many which blend the two in one proportion or another. RL> Obviously there is scope for both kinds to produce work with substance, RL> but it's a lot less likely in the latter. Agreed, but, as I mention above, how do you distinguish one from the other? RL> I enjoyed the star wars trilogy from the point of view that when it RL> first came out the effects were truly original and stunning. As did I and I agree that the effects were original and stunning, however that is the point I am making, the effects were done *so well* that they became de rigeur for virtually every other SF Film that followed. A sub note to this, do you remember a film called "Deep Star Six"? Apparantly the original title was "Deep Six", but the studio said "well, every successful SF film has 'star' in the title, so put it in here!" RL> The story was incidental. As mentioned elsewhere, it's standard Fantasy fare, just stuck in a SF setting. Substitute "Wizard's Tower" for "Death Star" and it could be any one of many cliched Sword and Sorcery tales. RL> Now I enjoy the likes of Blade Runner, which throws up questions about RL> where mankind is heading with it's experiments in genetics etc. Yes, I enjoyed Blade Runner too, but my point is that since Star Wars there have been too many "pretty pictures, no story or characters" films made and not enough like Blade Runner where it is the *characters* and the *plots* which are the important parts. RL> Anyway, I enjoy your discussions, Glad to hear it (mutters aside "at least someone does!" ;-) ) RL> I am new to all this Just a quick word, it's much easier if you can break your replies up into short paragraphs of maximum, say, five or six lines, as it's easier for the other person to reply to a message one "point" at a time. RL> keep up the good work. I'm planning on it! Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)