From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-11 02:45 · #74024 in PRATCHETT
Hi Paul, GM> But that's only two films out of *how many*? Why can't we have more GM> 2001's and Blade Runner's? What is it about these films that makes it GM> so difficult to produce others with plots and characters? PW> They were both based on books by excellent authors, and happened PW> to get a good director as well? Yes, they both had good directors, but each was only loosely based on the stories which inspired them. Clarke's "The Sentinel" only dealt with finding the alien artifact on the moon, the book was written contemperaneously with the film. Clarke said that he actually revised parts of the book *after* seeing some of the shots they were working on in the film and commented that it was a rather expensive way of writing a book! Blade Runner is based *extremely* loosely on "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?", as has been discussed many a time in here. PW> Even though Kubrick messed up the end of 2001, IMO Addressed in another thread. GM> My contention is that it has become too easy to put in flashy special GM> effects where the character and plot development ought to be. PW> That's not the fault of SW, though. That's the "fault" of technology in PW> general, for progressing to the point at which it became easy to do this Ok, yes, I take the point, but I maintain that because Star Wars did it *so well* that it completely changed the course of SF film production. I don't know what it would have been like if Star Wars had been a flop, but I can't say that I consider Star Wars to have been of total benefit to the SF film industry and SF fans in general. [Re: George Lucas] PW> As an interesting aside, it wasn't actually his idea to do all the PW> FX the way they were done, he was going to use models etc... Eh? I'm not sure what you mean. Star Wars *did* use models... Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)