Slimelite BBS

Libarys

Back to PRATCHETT

From Ian Muirhead · 1996-04-07 16:00 · #73891 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Libarys by Ray Barker

Ray Barker wrote in a message to Ian Muirhead:


 PW> I think it's a good series, myself. I also think that Weis and
 PW> Hickman are excellent authors, but that's just me.

 IM> I agree totally, what other W&H have you read, Star of the Guardians
 IM> tril, Darksword tril, rose of the prophets tril, etc.?

 RB> REALLY?!?!? The last book was COMPLETE KAK! W&H are usually
 RB> excellent. Usually. Except Darksword. And the last book of
 
The only Darksword book I didn't like was the third, It got too silly and had a stupid SF ending...

RB> Deathgate.

 RB> My reasons? Simple.


 RB> inadequately explained and  reasoned, almost as if W & H simply got
 RB> bored and finished up halfway into the ending. There is no sub-plot
 RB> or plot that excuses the ending, it is  simply unsatisfying
 RB> illogic.

It's not that bad, admittedly I would have been happier if they'd written a few more books in the series to tie up the loose ends, It's not that illogical,

[Spoiler]
























At the end they have to close the door, and prevent anybody from travelling from each realm again, the main room was mentioned as far back as book two, and each step was a logical decision until the end where they get trapped in the Nexus... Whats wrong with that?



By Your leave, Ian 

---
 * Origin:       I'm too sexy for this origin       (2:2501/10.1)