Slimelite BBS

Re: Libarys

Back to PRATCHETT

From Ray Barker · 1996-04-05 02:48 · #73824 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Libarys by Ray Barker

 As my Black&Ian PowerMuirhead bit into the eye of Paul Walker...

 PW> I think it's a good series, myself. I also think that Weis and
 PW> Hickman are excellent authors, but that's just me.

 IM> I agree totally, what other W&H have you read, Star of the Guardians
 IM> tril, Darksword tril, rose of the prophets tril, etc.?

REALLY?!?!? The last book was COMPLETE KAK! W&H are usually excellent.
Usually. Except Darksword. And the last book of Deathgate.
My reasons? Simple.
Alfred Hitchcock once stated that you cannot have a bomb under a table for 
half a film without it going off. 
Likewise, the last book in a cycle, particularly a _septology_ must deliver
what the other books promise. The decision at the end to go and live <if you
have read it you know, otherwise tough luck> is inadequately explained and 
reasoned, almost as if W & H simply got bored and finished up halfway into
the ending. There is no sub-plot or plot that excuses the ending, it is 
simply unsatisfying illogic.

... Go straight to the docs.  Do not pass GO.  Do not collect $200!
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Alba Maximus, Glasgow [Line1 0141 880 7863 V34] (2:259/2)