Slimelite BBS

Re: stl help

Back to EMULATE

From Chris Downs · 1996-04-07 19:04 · #73642 in EMULATE

In reply to stl help by Mike Bilow

 CD>  I bought Nelson's book.  It's quite good for a thorough
 CD> explanation of  the hows and wheres and whys of STL.  But
 CD> when I started working with  STL rather than just reading
 CD> about it, Nelson's book falls short.  His  index sucks and
 CD> the "samples" are almost always much too simple to be  of
 CD> use.

 MB> I disagree with your criticism of Nelson's book.  He is trying to use
 MB> the STL as a kind of tool to demonstrate the power of template design
 MB> in C++.  Given that broad objective, the reliance upon containers of
 MB> simple objects, including built-in types, is an excellent technique for
 MB> showing off his point.

 So where's the disagreement?  Do you think "thorough explanation" is
 some sort of slam?  Nelson does an excellent job of explaining the
 ins and out of STL.  Bus his book also sucks as a reference.  So once
 again, where do we disagree?

 MB> Nelson intends his narrative to be read as an annotation on the source
 MB> code, not as a cookbook.

 Your interpretation of Nelson's intentions may be accurate.  But the
 layout of his book says something else.  Nelson devotes about a third
 of his book to a reference section.  I expect a book with such an
 extensive reference to be something usable *AS* a reference.  But in
 this case, that just didn't hold up.

 Like I said, Nelson's tutorial is good.  But when I learn something,
 I need to tutorial to learn how.  But my experience with using _EVERY_
 software tool has been that I'll be using the reference a heck of a lot
 more than I'll use the tutorial.

 I checked out Nelson's book before I bought it.  I could tell that
 his explanations were first rate.  But since I lacked any experience
 with STL, I couldn't judge the effectiveness of his extensive
 reference section.  But after using it as a reference, I found it
 a pain.  If wasting your time wading through the tutorial makes sense
 for you (perhaps your employer doesn't mind that he's being billed
 while you're reading) then Nelson's book will fit all your needs.

 MB> My view is that Nelson teaches you how the STL works.  If you want a
 MB> quick treatment of how to use the STL, Nelson's book is pretty tough
 MB> going for that.

 What I want is for a book that will be useful for a long time and in
 as wide a variety of situations is possible.  Nelson's book is great
 for reading in bed or in the can.  But bringing the book over to the
 computer is a waste of desk space.


---
 þ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12 þ

--- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.12 
 * Origin:   (1:100/4.0)