From Mike Bilow · 1996-04-05 15:25 · #73601 in EMULATE
Chris Downs wrote in a message to Jerry Coffin: CD> I bought Nelson's book. It's quite good for a thorough CD> explanation of the hows and wheres and whys of STL. But CD> when I started working with STL rather than just reading CD> about it, Nelson's book falls short. His index sucks and CD> the "samples" are almost always much too simple to be of CD> use. He almost always makes queues of ints or chars so some CD> of the needs for programming "real life stuff" isn't in the CD> sample. So then you have to track through the text, blah, CD> blah, blah. CD> Then I picked up "STL <Primer>" by some dudes I can't CD> remember. It's a much better reference. I disagree with your criticism of Nelson's book. He is trying to use the STL as a kind of tool to demonstrate the power of template design in C++. Given that broad objective, the reliance upon containers of simple objects, including built-in types, is an excellent technique for showing off his point. Nelson intends his narrative to be read as an annotation on the source code, not as a cookbook. He is interested in the design issues underlying the STL, which are extremely important concepts to use as a teaching model about C++. My view is that Nelson teaches you how the STL works. If you want a quick treatment of how to use the STL, Nelson's book is pretty tough going for that. -- Mike --- * Origin: N1BEE BBS +1 401 944 8498 V.34/V.FC/V.32bis/HST16.8 (1:323/107)