From Patrick Patriarca · 1996-04-04 04:41 · #73227 in CONSOLES
In reply to Re: FTP SITE by Patrick Patriarca
Continued from the previous message... úÿ HG> 3.) Without user support, which helps them maintain their systems, HG> eventually it will leave many children and those too poor to have HG> Internet access with no where to turn when they finally pack up and HG> shut down. Ah .... the appeal to the poor and children. As a Social Worker who has lived in group homes 24 hrs a day, 7 days a week for 5 years (the Boy's Town type homes) with poor unwanted children AND began my career living in a public housing project for 4 years you are preaching to the choir!! In regards to quote #3: I disagree. IF Fidonet providers , who now provide a largely free service pack up and shut down that will be their chioce. THEY will cut off the poor and children. Not I. User support is a function of quality and affordability. Again ... people will go to the Internet if they can afford it. If they can't ..they won't. They will presumably stay with Fidonet. Fidonet will continue for a number of reasons ... if it is free (which it still largely is) and if it has quality products such as your SB-prefixed conferences and the SPACE Conference. I and others here belong to both Fido and InterNet... why are we still here in FidoNet??? Frankly because your conferences are better than many of the Internet conferences. To be afraid of competition any try to shut it out is the death nell of any endevour. SOunds to me like an attempt at embargo or tariffs against Internet. IF the above response from Fidonet is typical of it's leaders thinking then the future of Fidonet is doomed, not by a 10 meg FTP site but by their fear of and reaction to competition. I sense Fidonet is afraid AND jealous ... not too long ago Fido was the only show in town. Now a jazzier, hipper, more colorful newer competitor (WWW/Internet) has moved in ... Fidonet's reaction seems to be to not allow mention of the newcomer. Well, that won't make Internet/WWW go away nor will it prolong FidoNet's existence. So .... ...again .. why are regular/routine mention of WWW and Internet sites allowed but ANY mention of a 10 meg FTP site is not allowed ... my QUESS is because they don't DARE not allow mention of space related WWW/Internet sites (because such a public annoucement would drive away most WWW/ Internet people) ... but out of fear of the new NET in town they CAN stop mention of a 10 meg FTP site. They NEED something to blame. A 10 meg FTP site is it. So be it. Sad. But so be it. FidoNet's attitude (to the Internet NOT to my FTP site) brings a number of images to mind ... such as the fear of buggy and horse whip makers to the automobile ... the reaction of religions to Galileo, evolution (the Scope's trial) but moreso that of an ostrich's head in the sand. The last image is appropriate because the Internet is HERE ..it is here to stay and is getting cheaper ... AOL expensive type connects will either change or die. For instance AT&T just announced $20 per month unlimited access. The plan is for all connections to be local calls. Same for MCI etc. PLUS there are ever more local private Internet providers ... half a dozen in my semi-rural area alone. ALL for $20 a month. Heck ...many people LITERALLY urinate away that much beer in a month! Internet access will soon be within virtually everyones (those who can afford a $2000 computer) economic reach ... IF they want it... THAT is the reality and the reason for FidoNet's fear. NOT a 10 meg FTP site. Question is ...what is Fidonet's reaction to THAT reality? Apparently it is to not allow ANY mention of a 10 meg FTP site. Fine. As I said I will and have agreed. It's wrong, short-sighted, and self-defeating... but you know me. Ever the good soldier! Let me bring closure with how all this effects the SPACE conference and space discussion in general. I view FidoNet, the Internet (FTP sites) ,the WWW, NETwork TV, radio NETworks , Inter-library NETworks etc as ALL part of one GREAT NET of information. I move from one to the other with little thought except how can I glean the BEST data from each, condense it and share it with you all to further our fummbling, half blind attempt to become a space faring culture. Apparently Fidonet does not share my vision. According to your above 3 reasons Fidonet WANTS to lock out mention of Internet/WWW sites but can't. That's ok. Doesn't change much ...except perhaps mark the beginning of the end of FidoNet as a vital agent of the exchange of data regarding space. Perhaps as the saying goes .... "FidoNet is dead ... long live the InterNET." I sincerely hope not as FidoNet has long been a source of data, great discussions and debate for me. HG> They have pursuaded me and I have to agree, per the echo rules. HG> Thank you for your cooperation in this matter. Of course. I can understand your position in FidoNet ... I imagine I would react the same if in your position. You have enough to do dealing with unruley posters and annoyed Sysops who you have to contend with. Though I disagree I will comply ... some of my msgs. were sent out with the FTP address in the signature before receiving your call and the above post. I will not mention the issue again here. Please forgive this long response. You DID post me publicly, didnot say to not úÿ Continued in the next message... --- * Origin: Ground Zero - 813-849-4034 - gzero.com - REC18 (1:3619/25)