From Patrick Patriarca · 1996-04-04 04:41 · #73226 in CONSOLES
In reply to FTP SITE by Patrick Patriarca
HG> I've had some netmail over the past few months mate. Several sysops HG> and some users have written to me and pointed out your repeated HG> plugging I didn't think I was *plugging* it ... actually I had the FTP for a few weeks, lost it for a few months and recently got it back. That was why I mentioned it in a recent post ... I THINK the entire it may have been in my signature which I do not see when I post you all ... perhaps that was the problem. However, virtually ALL BBS's are mentioned in the taglines of posts so I fail to see the differance... In any event, rules are rules. I will comply. HG>of your private FTP site amounts to a BBS Ad, I honestly NEVER thought of a 10 meg FTP site as a BBS. It is not even close to a BBS however apparently it HG>is not allowed by the echo rules. As you know we discussed this when you called via phone. I appreciated the call as we discussed this issue and others of mutual interest. (DO visit Ostia Antica when you are in Italy on your honeymoon!) As I indicated over the phone I will, of course, agree to your reguest. You were very specific that I was "not to mention the address of the FTP site at all, anywhere in any posts." However, in thinking over the issue I have opted to respond one time since you posted me here publicly. More importantly it deals with an issue which not only involves the Space Conference, space related research and discussions in general but the future of both FidoNet, the Internet and the World Wide Web (WWW) ... note the differance between Internet and WWW. HG> So by the Rules of this Echo I have to ask you to please stop it in HG> here. There is an echo for BBS Ads. Maybe that place would be HG> better. I don't know. I will consider your suggestion re: the BBS Ads. Thank you for the suggestion. However, apparently it will not be welcome for I believe there is a deeper reason for not wanting mention of a 10 meg Internet FTP site...see below. HG> Summerizing the following points were also made. 1.) unless your HG> job, place of work or university provides you with access, the HG> majority have to pay to gain access the Internet. Considering that MANY WWW (Web PAges) and Internet sites are regularly mentioned (ie: NASA's, Jonathan's Space Reports etc) in SPACE and throughout FidoNet) these 3 reasons are apparently the REAL reason a 10 meg FTP site has been singled out. Now to respond to #1: Yes ..if some can afford Internet they may go to it ...if they can't , they don't. BTW ... I pay for access to Fidonet ... $25 per year. 2.) It was felt sending folks off to this mosly "pay for your access" Commercial Net Only hurts FIDO by deteriorating the base of contributing users. I am unsure if this is your deeply held opinion or one you need to accept politically (which I can understand) since you are heavily involved in Fidonet. In any event I must disagree. Surely the Internet is more expensive the Fidonet. However, the posting of a small FTP site surely is not going to convince anyone to go to the Internet and leave Fidonet. Simply put ... if someone has the money to afford Internet they will (and are) moving to it. If they don't they won't. WWW and Internet sites are regularly mentioned in all your conferences and through out Fidonet. You made it very clear to me I am not only NOT to put the address of my FTP site in my signature but to not mention the address at ALL in any of my posts. I agreed. In thinking about it later I wondered ... do the fine people of FidoNet (I mean that seriously as you all DO provide a largely free quality service) also mean to now NOT allow ANY posting of WWW and Internet sites in ANY posts... for instance ... the NASA WWW sites are regularly mentioned and referred to ... many other space related sites are mentioned (ex: Jonathan's Space report). SURELY as part of the WWW they are MUCH closer to the concept of a BBS (they are interactive which my FTP site is not. ie: people can leave msgs.) than my FTP site (which more accurately reflects the research origins of the Internet). IF mention of a 10 meg FTP site "sends people off to Internet ...and deteriorates the base of users" what are full blown Web Pages such as NASA's or Jonathan's Space Report Web Page doing?? Are mentions of ANY Internet or WWW sites also forbidden for the same reasons? THAT would be consistant. Yet I doubt and hope not. And if not then why is (let's say as often as Jonathan's Space Reportis mentioned) my 10 meg FTP site such a danger??? SURELY Nasa's groovey Web site is FAR more attractive than my dry, bare bones FTP site. I see a basic inconsistency here. The reason for which I will get to. úÿ Continued in the next message... --- * Origin: Ground Zero - 813-849-4034 - gzero.com - REC18 (1:3619/25)