Slimelite BBS

Re: How a new nodelist would work.....

Back to FREE25

From Leonard Erickson · 1996-04-11 00:15 · #73165 in FREE25

In reply to Re: How a new nodelist would work..... by Leonard Erickson

-=> Quoting Darr Hoag to Jason Steck <=-

 DH> e.g. take a look at my net's segment... 2330/1 is not my Hub - I
 DH> receive nothing from her (she's even a long distance call from me)... 
 DH> Tony put her as my Hub because as NEC she has the /1 address and that
 DH> address is numerically lower than mine(!). I've even asked him to read
 DH> FTS-5 and told him about just listing the nodes below their Hubs, or
 DH> above all the Hubs if they don't actually feed from any of them - that
 DH> numerical sequence wasn't necessary - and he said he 'didn't want to
 DH> do it that way', that way 'would not look neat' when viewed raw, and
 DH> that he would 'do it any way that he wanted to'.  (*8 

To start with, Hub lines, like Host lines are *duplicate* entries. That
is, the node in question is supposed to have another "normal" listing
with the same phone number.

Also, all that "Hub" signifies is that netmail for nodes listed under
that node may be sent to that node, and it will either be forwarded or
else there are arrangements such that the nodes under the hub poll the
hub frequently. It has *nothing* to do with echomail distribution.

The way most nets handle it is to divide the net into geographical
areas, and assign a hub to each area, then the nodes get assigned
numbers based on which hub they are under. For example we have hubs
numbered 100, 200, 300, etc. Nodes numbered 1xx are all in Vancouver.
Nodes numbered 2xx are in one set of suburbs, nodes numbered 300 are in
another set. And nodes numbered xx are in the core area (and more
recently we added nodes numbered 10xx to the core area). 

So our nodelist segment is mostly in order. Only the outlying nodes
directly under the NC are "out of order".

 DH> If you compare nodelisted Hubs to actual paths in the echos, I believe
 DH> you'll find many more examples of this, BTW....  I know as a moderator
 DH> I certainly have.  Cheers.  (*8 

I think you are getting "echomail hubs" confused with the Hub keyword
in the nodelist. Nodes marked Hub in the nodelist will deliver incoming
netmail to the nodes under them, just like nodes marked Host deliver
netmail to the nodes under them. As such, they *don't* appear in the
paths of echomail messages. 

Nodes that hub echomail *don't* get the Hub keyword on their listing.
They don't get any sort of special item in the nodelist at all.

Your NC is still wrong though. :-)

ps. You *really* should complain to your RC about this. Your NC is
causing mail to be misdelivered buy doing things the way you describe.
The nodelist is guaranteed to be screwed up if there are two or more
"Hub" entries in a row.



... Upgrade definition: Take the OLD bugs out, Put new ones in!
--- Blue Wave/DOS v2.30
 * Origin: Shadowshack (1:105/51)