Slimelite BBS

Re: How a new nodelist would work.....

Back to FREE25

From Leonard Erickson · 1996-04-10 22:26 · #73164 in FREE25

In reply to How a new nodelist would work..... by Jason Steck

-=> Quoting Jason Steck to Paul Edwards <=-

 JS> 1)  The utter unreliability and inefficiency of existing routed
 JS> netmail.  Even many /0 nodes cannot/will not reliably route inbound
 JS> mail and direct use of /0 inbound routing STILL requires a
 JS> long-distance call.  The routing system which follows echomail paths
 JS> is much more efficient, but suffers from massive areas where the
 JS> service is not available at all (due to many sites refusing to provide
 JS> the service) or where it has become completely unreliable due to the
 JS> presence of outdated software and obsolete user-neglected routing
 JS> tables. A large part of this problem is caused by large scale lack
 JS> of knowledge of and attention paid to the question of netmail routing.
 JS> This problem would be solved by putting the routing information in
 JS> the nodelist itself, thus removing both problems of individual sysop's
 JS> need for extensive routing education and the maintainence of
 JS> user-defined routing tables on each system in EVERY potential routing
 JS> chain. 

I'm afraid that you are sufferring from an excess of wishful thinking
here. You say the problem would be solved by putting the info in the
nodelist. You overlook the fact that this info will be no more accurate
than existing info, because there's nothing that *forces* people to
keep it correct. If a hub can't keep his routing tables correct, why
would he keep the routing info in his nodelist entry correct? Hell, I
know people who only have their *phone number* in the list right
because the NC tried to call them and couldn't get thru!

 JS> 2)  The problems in reaching other networks.  Right now, you need to
 JS> have either a physical copy of that other network's nodelist or you
 JS> need to have manually configured a route to someone else who does have
 JS> that kind of access.

Or you need to know that zonegates work for many of the other networks
too. They aren't perfect, because there are multiple networks using the
same zone number. But they do exists for some, and could be made to
exist for most.


... Disk Crash: (A)bort, (R)etry, (K)ill Innocent Bystanders?
--- Blue Wave/DOS v2.30
 * Origin: Shadowshack (1:105/51)