Slimelite BBS

An political question

Back to FREE25

From HECTOR SANTOS · 1996-04-08 09:54 · #73116 in FREE25

In reply to An political question by Pierre Phaneuf

Hello Pierre!

In a message to Hector Santos <04/05/96> Pierre Phaneuf wrote:

PP>>> Introduce bad addressing "just" for threading... When we're
PP>>> telling you that FTS-9 is *not* for addressing, but for threading,

HS>> Where in FTS-9 does it say its NOT for ADDRESSING? Show me that.

PP> I agree with you that it doesn't say any such thing. But the unwritten
PP> shouldn't take precedence over the written.

So why do you say the "UNWRITTEN" then?

PP> Use FTS-9 for addressing as long as you wish,

and I will too, because it works perfectly except for mail crosses the
rare "follow up" reply scenario and thats because chaining software is
ignoring the "message identification" of the specs.

PP> please, put the MSGID information in the REPLY *all* the time, as
PP> prescribed by FTS-9.

Not for "FOLLOW UP" situations. It doesn't make sense and it BREAKS the
"MESSAGE IDENTIFICATION" portion of the specs.  It may not break the
"CHAINING" portion of the specs but I will take ADDRESSING over the
CHAIN any day since that is more important for my user base.

There is no way on earth I will put a REPLY address that points to the
wrong person, especially when its created as a netmail response. It
simply doesn't make sense to put address in a netmail response that
points to nothing, not even the "thread".  So is an ECHO an exception?
Baloney.
--- Platinum Xpress/386/Wildcat! v1.2j
 * Origin: Xpress Tech Support BBS * 305-248-7815 (1:135/382)