From Pierre Phaneuf · 1996-04-10 08:02 · #73021 in FREE25
In reply to An political question by HECTOR SANTOS
HS>>> Where in FTS-9 does it say its NOT for ADDRESSING? Show me that. PP>> I agree with you that it doesn't say any such thing. But the PP>> unwritten shouldn't take precedence over the written. HS> So why do you say the "UNWRITTEN" then? Because it doesn't says anywhere it is FOR addressing... HS> Not for "FOLLOW UP" situations. It doesn't make sense and it BREAKS HS> the "MESSAGE IDENTIFICATION" portion of the specs. It may not break HS> the "CHAINING" portion of the specs but I will take ADDRESSING over HS> the CHAIN any day since that is more important for my user base. You don't seem to understand the words "message identification" must keep the "unique"? It is "message identification" like a BBS local message number, only that it is unique across the network... If it wasn't for renumbering, we could just put the address of the originating site and the message number and that would be it. See the similarity between the MSGID and the message number? The only difference is that the MSGID is unique all across the network at any time... In a local message base, you can't identify the *user* with the message number, it is the *message* that it identify... Same thing for the MSGID... I repeat it again, the fact that it works most of the time for addressing is only a side-effect, because most of the time it happen that replies are often destined to the author of the message we are replying to... HS> There is no way on earth I will put a REPLY address that points to HS> the wrong person, especially when its created as a netmail response. HS> It simply doesn't make sense to put address in a netmail response HS> that points to nothing, not even the "thread". So is an ECHO an HS> exception? HS> Baloney. The address in the MSGID is not to be considered as an address. This may sounds weird, but it is similar in fact that the first four chars of my Health Care Number (a number we have in Quebec, bureaucracy...) are the first four chars of my name... This is to add to the uniqueness of the number following it... We could use anything, it is just that the address is easy to get and is supposed to be unique... Hell, thinking of it, I could put my Health Care number in there, it is quite unique! The "address" is not *supposed* to point at anything, it is just supposed to be unique in the network... Note that in netmails, you have both an INTL line to give the address and a MSGID line to identify the message... If the address was already in the MSGID, why the INTL doesn't just have the destination address? (I know it's more complicated than that, but you catch my drift...) Pierre phaneuf@absint.login.qc.ca --- FMail/386 1.02 * Origin: Zaphod Beeblebrox for President! (1:167/136.14)