Slimelite BBS

Press & Compuserve Part-I

Back to CLUB_AMIGA

From Erik V. Petersen · 1996-04-08 20:26 · #70166 in CLUB_AMIGA

 JGr-rrr continued:
  
> EVP> Transcription is after-processing or re-write depending on the 
> EVP> capacity of the transcriber. In the Haynie transcript, Guidry
> EVP> walked a careful line cleaning up the worst noise and left most
> EVP> of the recorded transcript intact. (Nice Job, Jon! Thanks!). 
> EVP> Whereas a professional editor would have edited much more bru-
> EVP> tally, boiling the material down from 10% to 50% depending on 
> EVP> focus of visualized audience. He would have wiped out most 
> EVP> noise other than color, using paraphrasing paragraphs as glue.
  
JGr > So... let me see if I got this straight: one must be brutal to 
JGr > be protected under copyright law? One must be a "professional?"  
 
     Nonsense! I was illustrating different approaches. And if you 
don't think it can be brutal (on the editor) to boil down a 500-word 
piece to 50, then it is because you've never had to do it. Of course, 
the ones who had to do this regularly to meet deadlines and space 
requirements, must - according to you - be disallowed in this forum.

> JGr> How does a free newsletter differ from a quarter-a-copy newspa-
> JGr> per, other than the amount of money in the owners' pockets?  
 
> EVP> Newsletters are almost always vertical, special-interest publi-
> EVP> cations where a newspaper is a horizontal, wide-audience consu-
> EVP> mer product. Either can be produced professionally or amateur-
> EVP> ishly. Most lasting publications are produced professionally.
  
JGr > You didn't answer my question in the context of this discussion.  
JGr > If I wanted a definition of the word "newsletter" I could have 
JGr > looked it up...

     Snotty response unworthy of the Jeffy I thought I knew.

JGr > Let me be more specific, then:  How do copyright laws apply to 
JGr > "professional" publications and not "special-interest" publica-
JGr > tions?  Note that I am likely to make you eat the words "Spe-
JGr > cial Interest" if you're not very, very careful. :-)
 
     You haul that tired old horse into it continuously, don't you? 
You shout "COPYRIGHT" with righteous indignation, when a simple quote 
can be only a matter of copyright to a hair-splitting bunch of lawy-
ers lost in debate on precedents. I long since conceded that if you 
call Compuserve a publication, the transcript could not be quoted en 
toto. That's when I pointed out most professionals would not quote an 
entire transcript to get the message across but you scream thief when 
no theft is contemplated.
 
> JGr> The idea that one must be paid sums of cash in order to be con-
> JGr> sidered a professional does not work well for me, other than in 
> JGr> the letter of the law for certain situations.

> EVP> :-) :-) Do you really want to argue the definition of "profes-
> EVP> sional" on that basis? :-) 
  
JGr > I don't intend to base my evaluation of what's "Professional" on 
JGr > that, at all, which is why I said what I said.  

     Too bad the rest of the world disagrees.

JGr > What I'm wondering to myself is what YOUR idea of "professional" 

     I specified that but you discounted it. I'll rephrase: 

     A professional is someone who practises a certain craft or skill 
to make his living therefrom. He is presumably good enough at what he 
is doing to be paid for his services. One also presumes such a person 
has paid his/her dues via apprenticeship or other formal training. I 
also pointed out there may be low-standard pros vs gifted amateurs.
You keep insisting by your tone that I discount all but professional 
input. Never have. You on the other hand want to discount any pro-
fessionalism. I wonder why.
  
JGr > When it is not objectionable for me to photocopy and spread 
JGr > around YOUR work as "newsworthy" then I'll view that a bit more 
JGr > charitable. Until then, the protection has to apply to ALL.

     You started by calling me a sheapskate and end with the thieving 
epithet. When and where do you find me advocating "photo copying" of 
anything? This is wholly your own manufacture. And yes you CAN quote 
selectively even from a literary masterpiece. It is done every day in 
reviews.
                                                             --Erik


 | AmiQWK 2.9 - FREEWARE |
... Thesaurus: ancient reptile with an excellent vocabulary


--- DlgQWK v0.71a/PDQMail v2.60
 * Origin: Commodore Computer Club Vancouver B.C. (604-231-0363) (1:153/911)