From Erik V. Petersen · 1996-04-08 19:39 · #70165 in CLUB_AMIGA
The Grim One was fuming:
JGr > Maybe you CHOOSE to view it as apples and oranges, but I do not.
JGr > At the very core of your objection to CIS is that they are not
JGr > spreading thier information wide and far, free as the wind, sim-
JGr > ply because they're an electronic medium and you're used to
JGr > freebies from the electronic medium. If a newspaper charges you
JGr > $.25 to read an interview with Lee Iococca, you accept it com-
JGr > placently. If Time magazine charges you $2.00 to read an inter-
JGr > view with Mick Jagger, you accept it, plain and simple. Yet, if
JGr > CIS provides the same thing, an interview with Dave Haynie, you
JGr > balk at paying them the same fee you would to any of the other
JGr > non-electronic rags in the world.
Horsefeathers en masse! Now you're calling me a cheapskate becau-
se you've got my original message stuck crosswise in your gullet, now
shaped to fit your larynx and bearing no relation to my point.
Let's get back to the real issue and the original argument that
stemmed from Asha's post:
AD > The transcript of that conference is owned by the parcipants of
AD > that conference. In order to legally post it outside of Compu-
AD > serve you (or whoever wishes to do this) must get permission fro
AD > each and every person who posts on the conference including Dave
AD > Haynie. You can summerize, but you can't quote without permissi
evp-> Sorry M'Dear but this is bogus claptrap!
evp-> ANY PUBLIC UTTERING can be quoted by reponsible news media AND
evp-> anybody else who don't misquote and is willing to credit source.
This is legal quagmire but as I've already allowed, you may have
your point with a verbatum TRANSCRIPT when you consider Compuserve as
you do, a revered electronic PUBLISHER.
Where I took real issue was when Asha quoted CIS: "You can sum-
marize, but you can't quote without permission." And any of us -- how-
ever lowbred scum we may appear in your eyes -- professional communi-
cators will go nose-to-nose with you or any other disciples of the
currently fashionable electronic faith. You CAN ALWAYS quote as long
as you give full credit! When I subsequently mentioned "free" you
have distorted that into free as in freeloader when all the time I
was talking about free speech and freedom of press. That line is pure
legal bluff because you can *always* quote.
Next, I drew on my experience as a professional editor dealing
with nervous publishers and legal departments but by your sneering,
this is all invalid because it is from the old print press, predating
Miggy which is what this echo is about. I haven't heard from Joyce
yet so I doubt if I stressed Fido boundaries unduly.
Incidentally, Asha never took my immediate reaction personally
as you have chosen to do. We're old friends who've had disagreements
before. Not as close as you obviously but she's quite capable of de-
fending herself and on this point we merely chose to disagree sans
excessive rancor.
JGr > If I photocopied the previously mentioned interviews and spread
JGr > them around the world, I would be guilty in your eyes. If I did
JGr > the same with the Haynie interview, without permission, I get
JGr > the impression you'd cheer for me.
You're trying to make hole into high ground aren't you? In my
maligned print press era, getting scooped was a daily occupational
risk. You can't be everywhere all the time. The competition would run
an original story but because they had first dips that didn't mean
the rest of the field couldn't touch that story, although I gather
some of your current legal beagles are trying to sweep such under the
protective copyright rug. God help you all if they succeed.
This didn't mean the competition stole the story as you suggest.
The Sun would freely quote the News Herald on the breaking story and
then proceed to develop its own slant with different coverage. Like-
wise, I can now and in future quote Haynie from that Compuserve con-
ference, giving source, as filler or sidebar or part of any story I'd
produce. In such a case, Compuserve would not send its legal beagles
after me as suggested by the Asha statement. In fact they'd likely
appreciate the free publicity.
JGr > Conference, email forum, it doesn't matter. Either you respect
JGr > the laws of copyright, or you don't.
Stuck crosswise in your gullet.
JGr > And you're doing it again: apparently, only if one has gone
JGr > through years of trial and tribulation in the trenches are thier
JGr > words worthy of protection. Well, Erik, that positively reeks
JGr > and smacks of disrespect to many people who have important,
JGr > insightful things to say but haven't gone the same route you
JGr > have.
Never an issue and a postulation of your own fabrication. Is this
forum reserved for amateurs in all fields? We all are in some but dis-
regarding anything from a contributor because his background happens
to be professional seems rather wild and far-fetched.
(continued --Erik)
| AmiQWK 2.9 - FREEWARE |
... "Maybe the universe IS fuzzy?" -- Hubble Telescope Scientists
--- DlgQWK v0.71a/PDQMail v2.60
* Origin: Commodore Computer Club Vancouver B.C. (604-231-0363) (1:153/911)