Slimelite BBS

Re: Transistor voltage compare

Back to KERRANG

From Tony Frosdick · 1996-04-11 05:18 · #69158 in KERRANG

In reply to Re: Transistor voltage compare by Richard Gregory

Hi Richard
   In a message to Michel van der Heijden you wrote:

TF>The upper limit isn't the problem, 
TF>its the lower limit thats the problem because it would be running off 
TF>batteries. The 741 needs a minimum potential of 6V (although I'm using 8V 
TF>just to be sure). Also, the 0V I refer to is at the same potential as the 
TF>741's Vee. As you probably know the 741 won't work that close to it's 
TF>power rails. I've got around the 0V problem by biasing the input but this 
TF>isn't ideal because it makes the one input slightley non-linier. So what 
TF>I'm after is a transistor circuit that will compare two voltages without 
TF>the awkward supply voltage problem and the comparing close to the (0V) 
TF>supply rail problem. The comparer can still use a regulated voltage 
TF>source (a constant voltage is required by the other parts of the 
TF>circiut). The only thing I can think of is to invert one input and then 
TF>add it (via a bridge or potenial divider) and compare to +V/2, the 
TF>problem is I don't have enough data on transistors to work it all out. 
TF>But I can say with almost certainty that is won't be linier(though it 
TF>won't matter if both inputs suffer the same distortion).

   I think I am jumping into the middle of something here, but here goes :).
There are op-amps available which are happy to work with input voltages at
or close to the negative rail. The obvious ones compatible with the 741 are
LM358 (dual), LM324 (quad). Both of these have BAD crossover distortion if
you want to use them for anything more than a few hundred Hz. If you require
a comparator (and your message does suggest this) then a LM393 (dual) or LM339
(quad) should be ok but remember the comapators have open collector outputs.

   BTW, a little known fact is that LM351, 353 FET input amps are ok when the
inputs are at the +ve rail (just in case you need it).

Bye for now

Tony
--- FidoMail v.1.87 (21 Feb 1994)
 * Origin: A Point Off The Pleasure Dome (somewhere in Xanadu) (2:2501/10.2)