Slimelite BBS

Piffle

Back to REGION25

From Bill Birrell · 1996-04-07 14:29 · #69018 in REGION25

In reply to Piffle by Mike Jagdis

Hey Mike,

 > You should have quoted a little more then.

    No. I'm as bored as anybody with this once hot potato. That was plenty.

 > You made
 > claims that "anonymous" calls were equivalent to
 > "poison-pen letters" (no evidence, just a bald
 > statement).

    Misquote. Use the original Mike. I said the words "anonymous mail" and "poison-pen mail" were synonymous in our language. You have not denied that.

    However I will now stand on my hind legs and say something similar to what you have imputed to me, but perhaps a little more measured. Where anonymity is not the default (as it is in telephone calls) and it is used, then it is used to hide the identity of the author. There can be excellent reasons for anonymity or noms-de-plume, where prevailing social attitudes claim that only men can do certain things or are wrong in other equally silly ways, but there can also be the shabbiest of all reasons - escaping responsibility or culpability for malice and vituperation. How can you try to exclude that possibility? It flies in the face of reason and experience. I have even given you one concrete example of an obviously despicable use of the internet's anonymity server.

    Draw your own conclusions about why Policy 4 is anonymous. :-)

 > You were talking about how ACR and CLID
 > checking could be used to prevent "anonymous" calls
 > and make the world a nicer place.

    Not I. I have *never* advocated ACR. I *can* see why it might be useful on a voice line, but not on a data line. I have only refuted the silly claims
that it conflicted with Policy 4. I have been equally against using the "141" code on mailers. You have just been so passionately committed that you have not seen it.

 > No words have "been put in your mouth".

    No? What's all the above then?

 > Rather, I was asking you for your own words.

    You would talk the hind leg off a donkey, Mike, once your dander is up. I have asked you already to stop this pointless bickering twice. My own words follow at the end of this article.

 > BB>     It takes action at both ends for ACR and CLI withheld to
 > BB> prevent a connection.

 > So? I don't deny it. I have said that the blame should
 > not be purely 50/50 *in my opinion* but do not
 > challenge your right to hold a different opinion.

    Then that's all that need have been said. If that was all you had said in the first place then no disagreement would have occurred. You stated baldly that ACR must be banned because it conflicted with policy 4. I equally baldly disagree.

    It takes action at both ends for Policy 4 to be broken. Both ends are therefore part responsible for the breakdown, and because any resulting dispute can be resolved immediately by either party without reference to the other, anyone complaining is too easily annoyed. That is my position now and has been my position since I first discussed the matter with Ward Dossche as a fellow ZC over a month ago.

    Policy 4 says nothing whatsoever about CLI or ACR, and nobody is allowed to impose on sysops in FidoNet any conditions which are not included in that document.

Happy Easter, Mike,
Bill.

---
 * Origin: bill@escan.demon.co.uk (2:2504/200)