Slimelite BBS

Piffle

Back to REGION25

From Mike Jagdis · 1996-04-05 03:43 · #68970 in REGION25

In reply to Piffle by Bill Birrell

BB> > What makes such a call inherently
BB> > bad?

BB>     Who said it was bad?

You should have quoted a little more then. You made claims that "anonymous" calls were equivalent to "poison-pen letters" (no evidence, just a bald statement). You were talking about how ACR and CLID checking could be used to prevent "anonymous" calls and make the world a nicer place. I observed that you were using "anonymous" to mean "the caller chose not to give the number they called from". I asked why you seemed to think such calls were inherently bad. I do not accept that such calls are necessarily equivalent to poison-pen letters. I do not accept that a more or less arbitrary phone number can be considered an identity (certainly not for FTN or BBS purposes anyway). No words have "been put in your mouth". Rather, I was asking you for your own words.

BB>     It takes action at both ends for ACR and CLI withheld to
BB> prevent a connection.

So? I don't deny it. I have said that the blame should not be purely 50/50 *in my opinion* but do not challenge your right to hold a different opinion.

  I have said that CLI withhold has its uses and offered arguments as to how and why. I have also said that ACR appears to have no use other than to block a more or less arbitrary set of calls from a group of people that changes depending on circumstances which you cannot know nor predict.

  You, and others, seem to be off the opinion that ACR and CLID checking have real benefits. When I queried your statements you started talking about getting rid of "poison-pen letters", "perverts" and god knows what - but offered nothing but statements. I asked why and you start telling me I'm putting words into your mouth. Fine, take them out. Go back to square one. Does ACR and/or CLID checking have any intrinsic value when used in a public FTN? Explain your answer.

                                Mike  
 
---
 * Origin: The Purple Tentacle +44 1734 266974 (2:252/305)