From Mike Jagdis · 1996-04-06 23:07 · #68983 in REGION25
In reply to ACR by Bill Birrell
KF> MJ> The ability to send to and receive from any IFNA listed node
KF> MJ> during the Zone Mail Hour (eg. 9:00-10:00 UCT in Z1) is considered
KF> MJ> mandatory.
KF> MJ> Seems simple enough. You have to be able to receive from *any listed
KF> MJ> node* during ZMH. Bottom line.
KF> MJ> It doesn't matter what phone number they call from. It doesn't
KF> MJ> matter if they don't let you know what number they called from.
KF> That's _very_ selective. I read it as send to _and_ receive
KF> from... An ACR node can't receive from a 141 node and a 141
KF> node can't send to an ACR node.
Yes, a CLI withheld node can send to any listed node *except* a node that has ACR enabled and an ACR node can receive from any listed node *except* a node that is using CLI withheld.
However, there is a twist. The called node *must* be using ACR on the listed number (since this is the number called). There is no requirement that the calling node use the listed number for the outgoing call.
There are many and good reasons why a calling node might choose to withhold a number which is other than the listed number and there are many and good reasons why a node with more than one line might choose to use a non-listed line for outgoing calls. The identity of a node is the FTN address. The *only* association between identity and phone number is that the nodelist gives the phone number which you should *call* to reach that FTN address.
I feel that this biases the argument against ACR (perhaps not completely, but largely). To share the blame 50/50 you have to impose additional technical constraints - specifically that is is _necessary_ for a node to present CLI (it wasn't even _possible_ until recently) or that it is _necessary_ for a node to call out from the listed number.
Mike
---
* Origin: The Purple Tentacle +44 1734 266974 (2:252/305)