From Mike Jagdis · 1996-04-06 22:52 · #68982 in REGION25
In reply to Anon Call Rejection. by Daniel Shepperd
DS> MJ> There is no inherent "right" to a nodelisting. Nor is there any
DS> Surely if someone qualifies for a nodelisting then they have
DS> a right to it.
DS> [...]
DS> I totally fail to see the point you are making. Surely
DS> nodelisting is a right if a system meets the specified
DS> standards, of course they have to apply for it but that is
DS> only a matter of letting the *C know. Are you possibly
DS> refering to social XABs?
No. Qualifying for a nodelisting means you qualify for a nodelisting. There is nothing that grants you an inalienable (or even otherwise) "right" to a nodelisting. Laws and legal contracts may grant rights. Policy 4 might grant rights - if it had a chance of standing as a legally binding contract and if it could possibly apply *before* you were actually a node of FidoNet. Even then P4 only provides for removal of *Cs who are deemed not to have done their job by other *Cs. If someone doesn't want to give you a listing you can fight for one but you have no _right_ to one. NetMail a *C saying you have a board full of porn and warez that you want to put through FidoNet, demand a listing as is your "right" and sit back and watch the flamefest develop :-).
Mike
---
* Origin: The Purple Tentacle +44 1734 266974 (2:252/305)