Slimelite BBS

ACR

Back to REGION25

From Denis McMahon · 1996-04-02 06:55 · #68941 in REGION25

In reply to ACR by Mike Jagdis

Hi Mike

 It appears that on Sat 30 Mar 
 Mike Jagdis said to Denis McMahon ....

DM>> However, as far as the specifics of the ACR debate are concerned, the use 
DM>> of ACR does not prevent the receipt of FidoNet netmail.

MJ> How so? 

Simple, a call from a standard telephone line will always terminate succesfully to a line with ACR. Only calls from lines whose parameters have been altered by or at the request of the calling subscriber are unable to contact lines with ACR active.

MJ> Without any indication in the nodelist and without any means for a modem 
MJ> to identify it as a cause for failure it clearly does prevent the receipt 
MJ> of netmail. And callers are just as entitled to make use of 141 as 
MJ> callees are entitled to use ACR.

As I have recently been saying, either both should be prohibited, or both should be allowed. There is no technical basis in either FTS-0001 or P4 for permitting one and refusing the other. The arguments for both are sociological, and thus irrelevant. The fact that they may conflict makes me tend towards prohibiting both. However, if the proponents of both ACR and CLI withhold could accept that in the case of a call failure both sides were equally responsible, then perhaps both could be allowed.

Rgds
Denis

denis.mcmahon@f20.n251.z2.fidonet.org / dmcmahon@edlgu4.ericsson.se

--- MsgedSQB 3.30.02
 * Origin: SET UAFALTERNATE 1 00:00-06:00 (2:251/20)