From Mike Jagdis · 1996-03-31 05:20 · #68929 in REGION25
* In a message originally to Dave Langridge, Denis McMahon said:
DM> >> The ability to send to and receive from any IFNA listed node during the
DM> >> Zone Mail Hour (eg. 9:00-10:00 UCT in Z1) is considered mandatory.
DM> Then I am totally unable to find that statement in Policy 4
DM> anywhere.
It is, as I said, a quote from FTS-0001 not Policy 4.
DM> I then searched FTS-0001 rev 15 for instances of Zone, and
DM> found:
DM> [...]
DM> As this document post-dates P4, it does open up several cans
DM> of worms, including that of whether it is the place of the
DM> FTS to re-interpret P4 within FTS documents, and whether it
DM> is appropriate for a technical standard to define operating
DM> conditions of systems outside of the remit of that standard.
I quoted from a version that pre-dates (I believe) Policy 4. Not being a Policy geek I don't go round collecting these things, sorting them into order and puzzling over exactly what various combinations mean or can be made to mean.
DM> It's a bit like the IEE wiring regs saying that you have to
DM> turn the porch light on between 2 and 3 in the morning, and
DM> that if you don't your electricity supply can be cut off!
Actually wiring regs do tend to change every now and again. Then you have to update the wiring before you can make modifications. I doubt whether many would think such an approach has any use in a public, open, amateur netowkr such as FidoNet though.
DM> However, as far as the specifics of the ACR debate are
DM> concerned, the use of ACR does not prevent the receipt of
DM> FidoNet netmail.
How so? Without any indication in the nodelist and without any means for a modem to identify it as a cause for failure it clearly does prevent the receipt of netmail. And callers are just as entitled to make use of 141 as callees are entitled to use ACR.
Mike
---
* Origin: The Purple Tentacle +44 1734 266974 (2:252/305)