Slimelite BBS

This ACR nonsense

Back to REGION25

From Denis McMahon · 1996-04-01 03:36 · #68910 in REGION25

In reply to This ACR nonsense by Dave Langridge

Hi Dave

 It appears that on Fri 29 Mar 
 Dave Langridge said to Denis McMahon ....

DM>> Person a has a phone line. They control the characteristics of that
DM>> line. Person a wishes to call person b.

DM>> Person a has set charecteristics on their lines that prevent person
DM>> a calling person b. Person a can change the characteristics on
DM>> their line and the call will complete.

DL> Ok..so how the hell can person a *know* that without voice calling it 
DL> first?? Sorry but person b, whilst in a DATA network, has to be the one 
DL> who is technicaly out of order. Person a cannot do *anything* about his 
DL> line without *prior* knowledge of the conditions on person b's line. As I 
DL> said...in a DATA COMMUNICATION network that is just not on.

Hold on, I didn't say ACR. The characteristics could just as easily be a request for B number transfer, outgoing call barring, or 64K ISDN data.

As I've said before, and will continue to say, there is no technical basis for the use of any network service that might cause a call to fail when calling another Fido system, nor for the use of of any network service on a Fido line that might prevent a call completing. Therefore, the use of all such services should be prohibited until such time as a way for them to coexist can be found.

Any justification for the allowing of such potentially communication affecting services on sociological grounds is invalid from the point of view of both FTS-0001 and P4.
Rgds
Denis

denis.mcmahon@f20.n251.z2.fidonet.org / dmcmahon@edlgu4.ericsson.se

--- MsgedSQB 3.30.02
 * Origin: SET UAFALTERNATE 1 00:00-06:00 (2:251/20)