Slimelite BBS

ACR

Back to REGION25

From Denis McMahon · 1996-03-31 22:27 · #68909 in REGION25

Hi Dave

 It appears that on Thu 28 Mar 
 Dave Langridge said to Denis McMahon ....

DL>> BUT, NO ACR during ZMH, even if there IS a flag. 
DM>> Why? If the flag is there, then ACR is OK. All you have to do is set up 
DM>> specific dial on the flag. Not difficult.

DL> Not difficult at all, but IMHO, it goes against the 'spirit' of Fido. In 
DL> fact both ACR and CLI do but CLI doesn't cause as many problems, it would 
DL> seem. 

Neither ACR nor CLI withhold cause any problems except when the two collide. To date, the general lack of availability of ACR (Jersey Telecomm, some cable co's and a limited BT trial notwithstanding) have meant a low visibility of the problem. When it becomes available to everyone, and the telcos get the passing of the withheld flag sorted out, the situation will probably change.

There is no technical basis for either CLI withholding or ACR within either P4 or FTS-0001. Therefore, they should either be both prohibited, or both permitted. It seems that, without the use of appropriate flags, permitting them may in some circumstances cause call set-up failure. In that case, the only safe basis is to prohibit the use of both.

If we are going to allow the sociological arguments in favour of CLI withhold to colour the technical judgement, then we must also allow the sociological arguments in favour of ACR to carry the same weight.

Rgds
Denis

denis.mcmahon@f20.n251.z2.fidonet.org / dmcmahon@edlgu4.ericsson.se

--- MsgedSQB 3.30.02
 * Origin: SET UAFALTERNATE 1 00:00-06:00 (2:251/20)