Slimelite BBS

Re: Myra Hindley

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Paul Dickie · 1996-04-09 15:48 · #68722 in AMIGA_NF

In reply to Re: Myra Hindley by Paul Dickie

Greetings!

 DY> Anybody who has killed should not be released if they are unstable.

So, what criteria should be used to determine their "stability"?  Would you, 
for example, consider that the felon should admit to the murder, or else be 
locked up for the rest of his/her life?  For an innocent person, wrongfully 
convicted, that amounts to torture; such a "double-bind" situation was what 
drove Stefan Kisko quite insane in prison. He's no longer mad, though...

 >TS>Personally, I don't think that anyone should be incarcerated for
 >TS>life, unless they would be a danger to society on their release.
 DY> I agree. This is why I don't want Myra Hindley released. What she did 
 DY> was evil beyond belief and I don't think we can be sure that anyone
 DY> who  was once that evil, has since reformed. 

I cannot agree with that, for it seems unsupported by the facts. Yes, the 
crimes for which she was (rightly) convicted were unspeakably evil, but 
one must also consider how much those terrible crimes were due to the malign
influence of Ian Brady. 

After all, it was Brady who bought the tape-recorder so that he could record 
the pleading and screams of his young victims; it was Brady whose camera was 
used, and who bought the film, to photograph his young victims; it was Brady 
who drove up to the moors above Saddleworth to bury his victims. Hindley was
involved as a willing accomplice; she may have contributed to the planning
and commission of those dreadful crimes, but there seems little reason to 
suppose that she devised any of the crimes by herself, nor that she would 
ever devise or commit any crimes by herself, were she to be released.
 
 >TS> I mean, if you're gonna lock 'em up forever, you might as well just
 >TS> execute 'em IMHO :-\ 

 DY> Not exactly. While they are alive in prison, they can be pardoned and 
 DY> released if it is later proved that they didn't commit the crimes they
 DY> were convicted for, i.e. we avoid the Timothy Evans scenario.

Exactly!  That's why, although I'd have been perfectly happy for Brady and 
Hindley to have been executed, I am convinced that the death sentence 
remains an unsafe, unsound and unsatisfactory means of punishment. Brady was 
undoubtedly the instigator and initiator of those crimes, though it is 
arguable that he was insane at the time and has remained so thereafter; 
Hindley must surely have recognised that what was being done was wrong, yet
she seems to have succumbed to something like the "pack mentality" that could 
allow American soldiers to commit murders in Vietnam. Worse, had either Brady,
or Hindley (or both) been executed for their crimes -- for which they were 
undoubtedly guilty -- then so would Stefan Kisko, who was wholly innocent of 
the rape and murder of Leslie Molseed.

If there is to be any change in the law, or in sentencing policy, I'd want 
there to be a new offence created -- and created retrospectively -- of 
"wilfully or culpably hindering a defence". Thus, it would be an offence for 
the Crown and its barristers, etc, to have failed to pass on to Kisko's 
defenders the forensic evidence that led, eventually, to his acquittal and
release; it would equally be an offence for the police and Crown to have 
convicted Judith Ward "by ambush". If that means that a certain Minister of 
the Crown would be convicted thereby, that's just too bad...

Cheerio for now!
 
< Paul >

... I'm not opinionated, I'm always right
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Kneptune BBS (+44-161-777-8088) (2:250/109)