Slimelite BBS

Re: Myra Hindley

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Paul Dickie · 1996-04-09 16:43 · #68721 in AMIGA_NF

In reply to Myra Hindley by Tom Sulston

Greetings!

 >DM>So far as I am concerned, murderers should never be released.
 DY> I agree that some murderers should never be released. I also feel that
 DY> some child abusers and some rapists should never be released. 
 DY> However, I wouldn't put all murders in the same category. Most murders
 DY> are committed by husbands against their wives or vice versa, often in
 DY> a fit of rage. Whilst the crime cannot be excused, I wouldn't put them
 DY> on the same level as Myra Hindley.

Indeed; her crimes had a quite amazing degree of premeditation. However, it
would perhaps be useful to consider whether she would have committed *any* 
such offences, had she not encountered Ian Brady.  I'd contend that she 
wouldn't, though it's equally possible that she might have met Fred West!

Away from Brady -- who is certain to remain in jug (OK -- in an asylum for 
the criminally insane) for the remainder of his life -- she is much less of
a threat and, as she's said that she'd emigrate to France upon release, it 
seems not unreasonable to let her out on that condition. Of course, other 
conditions would also have to be attached, such as her not going within 
200 km of Simon Ogg...

 DY> Also the difference between murder, manslaughter and GBH is often a
 DY> case  or pure luck and/or the availability of a legal loophole.
 DY> This is why I would do away with the mandatory life sentence. Instead
 DY> I would *extend* the discretionary life sentence to a wider variety of
 DY> crimes.

The present system tends to confine for longer those "murderers" who are
wholly innocent of the crimes for which they were, wrongfully convicted;
this is because the parole system requires that the convict shall have come
to terms with the enormity of the offence and shall have expressed genuine 
remorse. For a person to have to admit to a crime he knows he did not commit,
else face perpetual incarceration, is surely one of the worst forms of mental
torment ever inflicted!

At one time, it used to be argued that there were no cases in British gaols 
of persons whose conviction was unsafe or that, at worst, such cases were few
indeed. But, after the release of so many convicted murderers -- the 
"Guildford" four, the "Birmingham" six, Judith Ward, Stefan Kisko, to name 
but a dozen -- we now know that the risk of wrongful conviction in the British 
courts is at least as great as that in other countries.  Elsewhere in the 
world, however, it seems doubtful that the Minister of Justice (the role 
analogous to that of the Home Secretary) would cheerfully proclaim that he 
wasn't "minded" to look at a case, or send a case for review, just because 
some evidence had come to light that would cast doubt upon the validity of 
the conviction(s). With such political considerations being applied to 
determinations of guilt, justice in the UK has thus become even less than a 
mere lottery...

 DY> IMHO the biggest crime problem in this country at present exists among
 DY> repeat offenders. To solve this problem, I think we ought to look 
 DY> seriously at the "three strikes and you're out" policy which has been 
 DY> adopted in the US. This produces bizzare cases e.g. the other day a
 DY> man was given life for stealing half a hamburger but you have to take
 DY> the whole history into account.

Oh, indeed! After all, the theft of a hamburger is a most *serious* offence!
It's only right that, with the threat of BSE/CJD, someone who stole a meat
product (with intent to endanger the public thereby) should receive the same
sentence as an actual killer...o-)

The law -- so far enacted in California, though mercifully not yet enacted 
across America -- seems to be inherently unjust, in that the felon is being 
punished not only for that offence and all others that s/he may have 
committed or admitted, but also for all offences that s/he may commit in the 
future. Not only is such a legal presumption of future guilt unfair -- as it
is obviously not supported by any tangible evidence -- but it may even be 
incorrect, as it is *possible* that the felon could be transformed in gaol 
into a law-abiding citizen.

Or do you still cling to the foolish notion that longer gaol terms actually 
*deter* criminals -- even though leading judges and senior police officers 
have, in the last year, declared that they do not?  

I've been saying, for some years, that the length or severity of the likely 
sentence has little or no effect on the likelihood of someone offending, and 
that there is only *one*, effective deterent -- and I do *not* mean hanging.
No, that deterence is the sure and certain knowledge by the would-be villain 
that s/he would be apprehended, convicted and sentenced for those crimes. 
As long as there remains any prospect of the crim evading responsibility for 
the crime, it doesn't matter how severe the penalty might be; in the belief 
that being caught is something that only happens to others, they would still 
continue with their crime(s).

Cheerio for now!
 
< Paul >

... It's only my opinion, but it's better than yours.  
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Kneptune BBS (+44-161-777-8088) (2:250/109)