From Scott Wade · 1996-04-06 22:02 · #65443 in HAM
In reply to Cause and Effect by Johnny Saisho
Captains's Log, Stardate 96262.6
TM>>> I spend much of my time thinking up unlikely explanations to plot
TM>>> bugs...here goes....
AS>> oh dear...:-))
TM>> Well, it's a living.
AS>>>> Episode: Cause and Effect.
TM>>> Here goes: They were wrong. The other ship, the Bozeman, had not in
TM>>> the loop for 80 years.
AS>> Ahh, knew there was summit that I had missed :-() ===cut===
AS>> Nice explanation but it all hangs on the fact that the Bozeman had been
AS>> in the loop for 80 years...lets have one that presumes they w
TM>> Well, they couldn't have been, as the loop didn't begin until Data 'fi
TM>> made the mistake of using the tractor beam (or was it the shuttle bay?)
TM>> causing the explosion. (We know that the explosion caused the loop, bec
TM>> they got out of it by preventing the explosion.) Does that make sense?
JS> I can understand where both of you are coming from but I have a pretty
JS> good explanation for this. The Bozeman appear from a "swirly thing
JS> alert!" type thing much like the Enterprise C's jump into the future in
JS> Yesterday's Enterprise. This means that the Bozeman caught in a loop a
JS> few days long, and at the end of these days they travel through a time
JS> rift. If this is so the crew of the Bozeman have only been in a loop
JS> for a few days. The Enterprise (D that is) is caught in a loop and so
JS> these events continue to occur.
I remember starting a thread on this very subject many moons ago ;) I must have been out longer than I thought - I missed out on this one ;) Anyway, I have a few thoughts on this:
You say that the Bozeman came through a time rift. Good idea...except that surely SOMETHING must change the future if that did happen. Like, the Enty-C was meant to be destroyed at the Klingon outpost. As it came through the anomaly, and therefore didn't, the future changed. So, surely SOMETHING must have happened to the Bozeman that affected reality. Even worse, the ship STAYED! I can think of so many variences of this - Time's Arrow for example. As soon as Twain was it? entered the future, things should have changed... I dunno - this time thing is very difficult to control ;)
Anyway, the crew of the Bozeman must be pretty thick ;))) I mean, the Enty-D was caught for 17.5 days. By then, they knew EXACTLY what was going to happen. Yet the crew of the Bozeman had not a CLUE!! Where's the echos from previous loops? And on that subject, if the crew of the Enty-D knew what bloody cards were coming next in the poker game, why the fu*% didn't they realise the tractor beam wouldn't *WORK!* :)
Sorry, this episode has SEVERE problems!! Still superb though!!
______ ___
(_ \ / FIDONET:2/251/38.1 ___)COTT \/\/ADE NET:To Be Announced
CO-SYSOP OF BURNING RUBBER: 01705 343875
Stardate Courtesy of the Amiga Stardate Converter V2.10 by Scott Wade
... I speculated the number 3 to be the number of chins on Commander Riker
--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
* Origin: ...Perhaps you would care for a bath... (2:251/38.1@Fidonet)