Slimelite BBS

Chinese herbology/Western viewpoints/n

Back to MUSIC_CONTACTS

From Gail Farquhar · 1996-04-08 08:04 · #77990 in MUSIC_CONTACTS

 -=> Quoting Edward G. Siceloff to Gail Farquhar <=-

 EGS> That is not saying, of course, that Chinese Traditional Medical
 EGS> therapies have answers for everything.  But they do have many answers
 EGS> to problems that exist in their diagnostic patterns that make people
 EGS> healthy again. You mentioned one of Murray's books.  I have two of
 EGS> his works and really like them.  They are very informative.  But
 EGS> sometimes I think that very often Naturopathic treats specific diseases
 EGS> and disorders rather than what is specifically causing them, an
 EGS> imbalanced person.  Again the western reduction of people to atomic
 EGS> particles and chemical reactions would seem to be at the bottom of the
 EGS> nutripathic philosophy, although I'm aware of some other influences
 EGS> too. Would like to see some more discussion of nutripathic as well as
 EGS> Chinese herbs and their diagnostic system here on the echo.
 EGS> thanks for the informative post
    Balancing all the paths that exist in herbalism is as hard as
trying to balance all the various religious pathways would be, isn't
it? I think Tierra took a good stab at attempting to balance
"traditional" western herbalism and "traditional" Chinese herbalism in
his book _Planetary Herbology_, although I find plenty there that I
can disagree with <G>. I've been having fun with Hoffman's _NEW
Holistic Herbal_ too, and like some of his ideas.
    Unfortunately, it seems that most people want a cut-and-dried,
this-is-gonna-work-for-everyone, take-these-and-you-can-continue-
your-bad-diet-and-still-be-healthy,take-what-I-recommend-and-be-
absolved-from-any-personal-responsibility-for-your-OWN-health kinda
answer, instead of a list of possibilities to try to find out what's
going to work for THEM answer, and those "miracle" answers don't seem
to exist in the world of herbal medicine any more than they do in the
world of allopathic medicine.
    As for naturopaths, I disagree that *all*, or even most,
naturopaths take the piecemeal approach, although I agree with you
that Murray sometimes seems to do so. Snag a copy of _Naturopathic
Handbook of Herbal Formulas_ FOURTH edition, from Herbal Research
Publications, Inc. P.O. Box 721, Ayer, Massachusetts 01432 (we found
one "reduced for quick sale" at a local HFS) and check out the
intro...."Balance in Nature--Holistic Perspective on the Use of
Medicinal Plants", for a different take on this one. The book is
*really* a nice addition to any library, and has, among other things,
good listings of herbs that are contraindicated during pregnancy,
etc., etc. Since Linda Rector-Page, N.D.,Ph.D., in her (_How to be
Your Own Herbal Pharmacist_, a book on compounding herbal formulas)
takes a somewhat similar approach, perhaps a more holistic viewpoint
is the "new way" in Naturopathic medicine?? I dunno.....
    Here's hoping we DO get a wider range of discussions going 'round
here.

--- FreeMail/Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: The Wizards Realm BBS 1-713-946-7315 1:106/7315 (1:106/7315)