From Vince Coen · 1996-03-31 20:00 · #77791 in AWOL
Hello Vince! Wednesday March 27 1996, Vince Chadwick writes to All: VC> Here's another question to ponder. The RAF say the pilots erred in VC> flying their Chinook too low too near land; by the time they commenced VC> their climb, it was too late and they flew into the hill. Bit omitted.... VC> The Scottish civilian court does not blame the pilots. Did the VC> Sherrif chicken out, or does anyone think there is any doubt about VC> the RAF's verdict of pilot error? What this does not show (and it wasn't indicated at the civil court) was that the Chinook had some avigation equipment on board that had NOT proved itself. Many Chinook pilots were wary of it but I understand it was SOP to use it. In the case of one of the pilots of this specific aircraft, commenting to his father that it was a possibility that a accident would occur and that the natural conclusion would be pilot error if the problems of this equipment was not mentioned at the hearing and that he should disregard such findings. It is of course normal for 'CoE' to find against pilots unless the obvious facts is sitting in front of them. (Yes I am being very polite). The RAF hearing I understand no comment was placed or attributed to said equipment where as in the scottish court it was brought up as a possible cause but with no proof. I trust this explains the discrepancy and indicates the total impartiality of the RAF court of inquiry (sic). Vince PS. In the event that anyone on the COEO does not like these comments I suggest they PROVE me wrong. --- ADEPT 1.07/GoldED/2 2.50+#10UK3 under OS/2 * Origin: Air Applewood; OS/2 Gateway to Essex +44-1279-792300 (2:257/609)