Slimelite BBS

What do we need to be an artificially

Back to X_FILES

From Lee Davison · 1996-04-13 04:36 · #77549 in X_FILES

In reply to What do we need to be an artificially by David Otton

Hi David !

In a message of 02 Apr 96 David Otton wrote to me:

 DO>  Ok, we'll assume an easy way to get the thing running. Now, how do you
 DO> get the energy from the motor to all the places it's needed?

Any number of ways, a generator could convert the mechanical energy to electrical and then distributed via wiring or you could compress a gas or fluid and pipe that round.

 LD>> Well most organic fats are liquid
 DO>  Right, we'll use one of them. Can they be produced on a large enough
 DO> scale? A reusable source might be nice, so maybe a crop.

No problem, there are grain crops that produce useable oils, sunflower, rape seed, olive etc. The exhaust will smell nice too! 8^)=

 DO>  Surely the same problem applies to an engine that burns fat? Or are
 DO> you imagining a solid rod of fat being pushed into the burner like a
 DO> lipstick?

I wasn't but that's not I bad idea. What I thought was flexible bags with a sponge like core. The plastic outer cover is elastic and keeps the contents under (small) pressure. Filling is via non return valves.

 DO>  I don't think candles and lamps are applicable here; for all intents
 DO> and purposes the steam engine was a completely new technology and all
 DO> engine design began then.

Steam engines were new in egyptian times but didn't really become practical until the industrial revolution. However there were steam powered toys that used a steam jet to rotate some part.

 LD>> The brain of something cute-and-furry doesn't feel pain from cutting
 LD>> injuries as the required pain receptors are missing. For this reasom
 LD>> most delicate brain surgery is done under only local anesthetic (sp?)
 LD>> with the patient wide awake to report any odd sensations.

 DO>  Nice one. How about, all animals feel pain, a neural net cannot,

Only because it's not built to.

 DO> so a neural net is not alive.

Hmmmm.

 DO> Or, the net can be rebuilt /exactly/ as it was
 DO> before the links were cut. The mouse (or whatever) cannot.

That is due to a lack of biological technology on our part, cells can be removed from a brain and kept alive in vitro for indefinite periods. They can also be made to fuse into larger masses that exhibit the same behaviour as a neural net.

If we could take a brain apart and re-build it without destroying the cells it would be like a new brain and need re-programming with it's life experiences. The same is true for a neural net of any complexity so while you maintain the gross physical structure of both the identity would be lost.

I see no real difference between dismantling a working neural net and taking the brain of a small furry creature apart, neither is self aware or feel pain directly, both show aparent distress, neither can be rebuilt exactly as before.

What if the neural net was pleading for you to stop?

Cheers,
     __
 __ ///  Lee Davison :- Sysop
 \\X//  The Unseen University
  ~~~


--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
 * Origin: Lee's laboratory (2:2500/167.42)