From alex@forestbk.demon.co.uk · 1996-03-30 02:55 · #77531 in UFO
From: Alex McLean <alex@forestbk.demon.co.uk> Subject: Re: Encryption- Say What? Organization: The Forest Bookshop Date: Fri, 29 Mar 1996 20:55:45 GMT Apologies for this follow-up to a very old post - only just found it. In article: <000001JE.2.254.151.6@fido.zetnet.co.uk> Guy.Glover@p6.f151.n254.z2.fido.zetnet.co.uk (Guy Glover) writes: > > FidoTo: Alexm@Zeus > AL> But surely the reverse is true? It is currently harder to get > AL> authority for phone taps (and I see none arguing that clipper > AL> decrypt warrants should be any easier than phone taps) than > AL> for search warrants. This is as you would expect and should > AL> continue. > > AL> I can't see something as quick, easy and undetectable as > AL> decryption needing any kind of authority. You can't trust > AL> anyone with that kind of power today, and you don't know who > AL> is going to inherit this power in the future. > > So your argument is not against decryption at all, it is against > anyone having to power to to tap telephone lines full stop. Tapping voice supposedly comes with a built-in restriction - you need to have human operator monitoring the line, or a hell of a lot of CPU time. > You have to remember that no one is arguing for anyone to have the > right to tap into anything they choose. they can not do that now, > with analogue transmissions. The arguments effectively relate to > giving the same facilities on digital. Duncan Campbell, the journalist who revealed the purpose of GCHQ and who is a big authority on the security services, is convinced that all journalists have their e-mail routinely monitored. If this is true (I believe it's at least possible), it's done outside the law, but we have no way of knowing. Wether it's true or not, my point is that the ability to read all digital communications is placing a *huge* amount of power in the hands of the select few. Voice is not plaintext, it needs a human to be able to decode it anywhere near reliably. E-mail is plaintext, and so scanning on a massive scale is easily possible. > AL> I don't think the law is enough to control it. > > But you haven't even seen the proposed law as there is not one! 'Law' in the general sense of the word - I don't think any law is enough to control the monitoring of a centralised public communications system. Alex -- http://area51.upsu.plym.ac.uk/~alex/ Sysadmin, web master, bbs sysop, linux hacker - for hire. --- * Origin: ZETNET Usenet gateway (2:250/107.3)