Slimelite BBS

Come on people....!

Back to TREK.UK

From Timothy Edward Morgan · 1996-04-14 00:26 · #77528 in TREK.UK

In reply to Come on people....! by Graham Marsden

I put down my copy of "How to Become a Minor Dark Lord in 13 Easy Lessons" and
turned to read Graham Marsden's message about Come on people....!.

[Manly Pursuits: weapon-collecting]
Hmmm. "Manly Pursuits"... wouldn't that be a good name for a character?

 GM> Do you think this stems all the way back to the early days of Gygax and
 GM> co who originally created RPGs from a Wargames background?
Well, to the early days, anyway - I'm not sure that you can *blame* the
original authors for the way D&D turned out.  After all, a lot of the ideas we
play around with now had to evolve, or be imported from other fields that
Gygax et al. might have had no familiarity with.

 GM> ISTM that the emphasis has almost always been on becoming more and more
 GM> powerful, getting more hits, doing more damage, better armour etc and
 GM> less on "intellectual development".
Which boils down to the game's origin in wargames again - a better character,
for those purposes, being a better killer.  This has been enshrined in the XP
system, which is why people have to "go out and kill things" if they want to
have the fun of watching their characters develop.

As I said elsewhere, there are better ways of allocating experience points - to
fighters for sparring, to clerics for learning holy writ/ritual/whatever, and
so on.  All right, first-edition assassins can get XP for killing things - but
I'd let their players gain XP for studying "chemistry" (amongst other things),
too...

 GM> Could this be changed? *Should* it be changed?
Didn't I just tell you? ;)

[Games without large-scale corpse coolings]
 GM> But surely just losing a character isn't something that would put female
 GM> players off, would it?
No, not as a group, but if I were a woman I might be put off by the sort of
crude inanity that some players (the "Wh(o/at)-can-I-rape-next" brigade come to
mind at once) enjoy.  These twerps are a lot more likely to play games with a
high body count... it's the way they seem to think.  Likewise, I don't think
that I'd enjoy playing RPGs with militant (and I do mean militant) feminists.

This is a bit beside the point, anyway, because I didn't mean to imply that
violent games actually repel women.  There's no difference between the sexes
there - I learned how to use a broadsword from a woman, after all - but I do
think that there's less overall interest in making things go boom.  Since
that's a major part of most RPGs...

[A campaign without lethal combat]
 GM> But would the *male* players like that?
As if it matters! ;)  Seriously, I think that a good GM can provide enough
excitement and danger to satisfy most players without anyone actually killing
an NPC.

 GM> Oh dear, another sad RPGer who can't get a woman... ;-)
Of course - why do you think I took up RPGs in the first place? ;))

 GM> The "I can kill anything" egotrips might be ok occasionally or when you're
 GM> a teenager, but there's more to life than that...
Well, there is sex.  But only if you don't play RPGs ;)
--- Terminate 3.00/Pro
 * Origin: The Ephemeral Library (2:2502/666.969)