From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-14 02:22 · #77517 in TREK.UK
Hi Ian, [Re: One message and we get no less than *three* meaty topics] IM> Indeed, and it's got everybody out of the woodwork, I rever IM> realised there were this many people in here :) I never knew there was so much in it! ;-) I'm impressed!! [Re: CCGs vs RPGs] GM> the problem with conventional RPGs is that they require too much GM> organisation and coordination... IM> If you can't sort it out, join a club, I did, and from that, I'm now IM> going around other members houses to run/play games out of club hours... IM> and it's not that difficult to sort out, set a date and time, a IM> free afternoon for example, and you're away... How old are you? Are you working or a student or unemployed? When I and my friends were students, yes, it was easy to RPG at any time. After we graduated and some of us were unemployed, again, it was simple. Unfortunately as people started to get jobs and careers time considerations began to interfere more and more. GM> CCGs require a *lot* less planning and organisation. IM> It's not the same as a rpg however, theres no character interaction IM> it's not exactly what I'd call engrosssing... Yes, it's not the same as RPGing, but, IMO, it *is* engrossing. I've played in some ongoing games where you play a few games, then modify your deck according to what your opponent's got (and, of course, they are doing exactly the same), play again and so on... IM> most of the people who play this type of game have briefcases full of IM> them, each deck carefully tuned, if the only way to get a decent set is IM> to buy about L1000 worth of decks, it's a licence to print money... Yes and no. I agree that you can buy your way to success (and, indeed, many people have), but I haven't bought any cards for a long while now, I have enough cards and enough variety for what I need. GM> Several RPG companies jumped on the CCG band wagon, but I think GM> several of them fell of in a spectacular manner too! IM> T$R is doggedly staying on with its spellfire series, even though IM> from what I hear nobody plays it... I certainly don't know anyone who plays it and I haven't seen the cards in the shops either. Maybe it's a big success in the USA. [Re: CCGs are going to change the face of RPGs forever] GM> future games will rely a lot more on the roleplaying aspect IM> Quite a few of the games being released this year (ie, T$Rs IM> Dragonlance: Fifth Age rpg) are having the dice replaced with cards I think that's just an attempt to cash in on the CCG boom, although the use of cards in an RPG isn't actually new, there have been a couple that I have heard of before (although I can't remember any names). GM> I don't think that the RPG industry is going to die, but it is well GM> overdue for a large amount of soul searching. IM> I've got no problem with piles of dice, and I suspect that many IM> other gamers feel the same way... Hmm, piles of dice are OK for wargames, but I think that their time in RPGs has come and gone and that people are becoming less willing to leave everything to the roll of a die. Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)