Slimelite BBS

The Storyteller Thread

Back to TREK.UK

From Aaron Carr · 1996-04-12 20:51 · #77500 in TREK.UK

<You know this bit below \|/ Its Eoghann Irving quoting Aaron Carr, OK?>
 EI> I'm not sure there is realy much difference in terms of rules.i.e
 EI> there are still far too many.  For an RPG to be like a story it needs
 EI> to be very rules light.

I agree with you in that, but IMHO if you skip through a storyteller
book (eg Vampire) and then through a 'regular' rpg like ad&d then I'm
sure you'll agree that there are many, many less Tables/Charts, random
dice rolls and much more background, atmosphere/setting descriptions 
(and pretentious crap) in the Vampire Book.

 EI> All most of these systems seem to do is push the atmosphere a little
 EI> bit harder. Its a start, but I think theres a bit more needed than
 EI> that. 

I think that much is placed on the style of play given by the GM and 
his players.  Vampire _can_ be played with d10s swarming over a 
central table, with constant shouts of 'ahhhhhhh haaaaa, a 10'.  Or
it can be people sitting/standing around a room, hardly ever looking
at a characters sheet (ie much more freeform).  This can be done with
any system, although I know many systems which 'push' in a particular
direction, IMHO ad&d has a tendancy to promote a 'dice intensive'
game (which for some people is better), whereas i've found that a 
game like Ars Magica results in more freeform sessions (not that
I'm disputing that Magica contains quite a hefty amount of rules).

Well met,

Aaron.

... It's just another quiet day here at Pearl HarbourNO CARRIERS
___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12

Two wrongs don't make a right.  It usually takes three or more.

--- Hqwk V6.5 [IOSmail 0.89] 
 * Origin: The Druid +44 (0)1745 853503 Wales UK (2:442/23@fidonet.org)