Slimelite BBS

Re: Come on people....!

Back to TREK.UK

From Paul Walker · 1996-04-13 05:21 · #77494 in TREK.UK

In reply to Re: Come on people....! by Paul Walker

Hi Graham,

Quoting Graham Marsden to Paul Walker, on 08 Apr 96  14:37:00,
about Come on people....!.

 GM> [Re: CCG's (such as Magic, Rage etc) actually *help* the RPG industry]
 GM> Hmm, this should be interesting! As you are probably aware by now
 GM> there's another thread saying that CCGs are *killing* the RPG industry!

Yeah, I uploaded my replies, downloaded the mail, opened it and there was
another thread, the exact opposite of my own! :-)
 
 PW> Reason : people will see the cards, and be on the lookout for anything
 PW> similar. Let's face it, RPG's and M:tG are at least superficially
 PW> similar (spells, dragons etc), and so people will pick one up to try.
 GM> Well it's a different point of view, at least!

I've always been told I think slightly differently to other people. ;-)

 GM> I think one problem is that the established Roleplayers have found
 GM> their groups being stripped of members as they have all "gone over" to
 GM> the "new thing" because it's clever and different. This means that less
 GM> people are playing RPGs and those that are feel betrayed by the new
 GM> games. 

Maybe, but the craze won't last. As I've said in my message to Ian, the number
of people who play Magic (or other games, for that matter) is falling, slowly.
I think it *was* a sort of craze - it just happened to last a bit longer than,
for example, Pogs.

 GM> The other problem is that there are other shops apart from the
 GM> specialist games shops which are selling CCGs, including computer game
 GM> shops and even some of the large chain stores, so whilst it might get
 GM> *some* new people into the games shops, it might not get as many as you
 GM> might hope. 

Maybe, but *any* new people is (are?) to be welcomed, neh? [Argh! I got myself
into a real knot with the grammar of that sentence! :)]

There are only two people that I know of that have CCGs in Gloucester - one
of them's a mostly computer shop, as you said, the other one deals with RPGs,
comics, second-hand books, etc. (The Hobbit Hole - it's advertised in Arcane 
and SFX, so it can't be doing that badly).

 GM> The question is, of course, what will happen to the new players when
 GM> CCGs start to become stale (if, indeed, they are not already becoming
 GM> so). Will they start looking for other ways to enjoy that sort of thing
 GM> and get into RPGs or will they simply drift away and go onto other
 GM> things? 

There's bound to be *some* of them who start playing RPGs - and as I've said
above, any increase is welcome (better sentence that time! :)

I think there's a very serious problem with the CCG market at the moment - 
there's just too many of them. The industry cannot continue to support this
many games. Eventually (and this is speculation) it will fall down to some
games which hang on, but have nothing like the number of players they do at
the moment.

What happens to the players of the CCGs, I don't know. However, it's a fairly
safe bet that at least some of them will start playing RPGs.

 _
|_)                      
|  aul                   paul.walker@esoftc.seuk.com     <No files>

... C-ing is believing
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Highlander BB's - Gloucester [ +44-1452-384702/557 ] (2:253/418)