From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-11 07:33 · #77480 in TREK.UK
Hi Eoghann, [Reasons there are so few women RPGers] TEM> The bias towards "manly pursuits" can put some poeple - and not just TEM> women - off. It bores me, too, when people are playing the TEM> weapons-and-armour "collection game". EI> Yes, I gave up on RPGs for several years because of that style of EI> play. All those 36th level PCs began to seem a little silly. I agree entirely. Once I grew out of the "bigger is better" mentality I've had more fun playing a first level character surviving on his wits than on any 43rd level Fighter/ Paladin/ Ranger/ Magic User/ Thief. EI> I think the editor of Interactive Fantasy was suggesting things be taken EI> a step further. As I read it he was suggesting a game where fighting EI> simply wasn't a feature. Or at least was hardly a feature. And a good thing too! The old style games were all very much "combat oriented", to the extent that in D&D about the *only* way to advance your character was by killing things! Surprisingly enough there *are* ways of getting ahead in life without simply butchering anything that gets in your way! TEM> The point I'd like to make here is that you could have a campaign TEM> without lethal combat - in D&D, for instance, you could have the PCs TEM> sworn not to take life. EI> Yes, but you would have to have combat. The mechanics of D&D make EI> it essential. I disagree. As long as you are willing to either throw the D&D experience system out of the window or *heavily* modify it so you can get XP for *NOT* fighting, D&D can be played in this way. EI> Still it's an interesting concept. The players would have to be much EI> more imaginative than usual. And a damn good thing too!! EI> Imagine trying to subdue a dragon. :) I know this was supposed to be a joke, but something that rarely seems to be appreciated is that *monsters have feelings too*! That dragon doesn't simply exist to give the players more experience, it has its own needs, wants, desires etc. How about making the players *negotiate* with the dragon? Dragons aren't stupid for gods' sake! Evil, mean, callous and cruel, perhaps, but definitely *not* stupid. If a dragon is terrorising a town there is a *reason* for it. The PCs have to find out *why* it is doing it and then think of a way in which they can stop the dragon without engaging in (suicidal) combat. IMO that might well be a scenario where female players would be better than their male counterparts. TEM> [Whether it matters] TEM> The mixed-sex groups I've played in have usually been more fun than TEM> all-male groups. EI> Having a woman in a group certainly seems to stop some of the sillyness EI> thats inclined to go on otherwise. True. EI> Perhaps the fact that so few women are into RPGs is why they have such a EI> different outlook on them. Or perhaps that the (male) GMs are simply unwilling/ unable to cater to that outlook? [Re: Alternatives to Conanism] TEM> Story-telling, and having a good time. EI> I've been working on a set of rules that would allow people to take a EI> more storytelling approach to roleplaying. I'm having a little more EI> trouble with the character creation system though. I want it to be EI> quick but relatively freeform and to give guidelines. I may be asking EI> the impossible. :) Eoghann, if you would like to post some details of this to me privately, I would be interested in seeing them. You can either netmail me, e-mail me at graham.marsden@metricom.seuk.com, or give me a bell on (01705) 642149. EI> The hardest bit I think would be coming up with appropriate scenarios EI> for the characters. Its not that there aren't plenty of possibilities, EI> it's just that you get so used to thinking in terms of combat. That's just a matter of being willing to use your brain rather than your muscles. I know it's harder, but it *can* be done!! Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)