Slimelite BBS

Re: Come on people....!

Back to TREK.UK

From Eoghann Irving · 1996-04-12 02:22 · #77470 in TREK.UK

In reply to Come on people....! by Graham Marsden

It was 08 Apr 96 when Graham Marsden turned to Timothy Edward Morgan and uttered these fatefull words:


 GM> [Reasons there are so few women RPGers]

 TEM>> The bias towards "manly pursuits" can put some poeple - and not just
 TEM>> women - off. It bores me, too, when people are playing the
 
 GM> Do you think this stems all the way back to the early days of Gygax and
 GM> co who originally created RPGs from a Wargames background?

It almost certainly has something to do with it.  Mind you, films tend to  have a rather strong emphasis on manly persuits and so do most fantasy books and older SF too.

 GM> ISTM that the emphasis has almost always been on becoming more and more
 GM> powerful, getting more hits, doing more damage, better armour etc and
 GM> less on "intellectual development".

Well that was how D&D defined advancing the character wasn't it.  It was bound to shape peoples perceptions.

 GM> Could this be changed? *Should* it be changed?

I think it could be changed to some extent at least.  Should it be changed? That sort of depends on what sort of game you enjoy.  I'm not really into spoiling other peoples fun, but I think a wider variety of game styles would be nice.

 TEM>> [Games which are exceptions to this trend]

 GM> But surely just losing a character isn't something that would put
 GM> female players off, would it?

In fact it was the heavy emphasis on questing and violence which was suggested as the problem, not death.  Which is after all inevitable. :(

 GM> I'm not familiar with B&B or TFOS, but I've played Toon and that has
 GM> the capacity for being the *most* violent *because* you can't lose
 GM> characters. Ok, yes, it's "cartoon" violence, but violence none the
 GM> less.

The original suggestion seemed to rely on the idea that women were more into problem solving.  Its a commonly held opinion, but is it true?

 TEM>> The point I'd like to make here is that you could have a campaign
 TEM>> without lethal combat - in D&D, for instance, you could have the PCs
 TEM>> sworn not to take life.

 GM> But would the *male* players like that?

The single biggest problem.  There really is nothing like a group of men together to put women off. :)

Have Fun,


Eoghann

     ************************************************************
     ***   New SUPER SIZZLE.  It's SO good we ate the baby!   ***
     ************************************************************

--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
 * Origin: A deeply distrubed mind (2:440/302.14@FidoNet)